Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA

Add to wishlist
Add to compare
Add a photo
177 photos
Get pizza at Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA
Meals at Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA
Food at Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA
Meals at Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA
Food at Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA
Meals at Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA
Food at Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA
Add a photo
Add your opinion

Savor Italian cuisine that will combine many elements of culinary traditions. Many visitors come here to enjoy nicely cooked double pizza, pies and sausages. This pizzeria guarantees you good cannolis and tasty tiramisu. Don't miss the opportunity to order delicious wine or good draft beer. Great coffee is served - try and enjoy.

At Arcaro & Genell, you can get a takeout. The gracious staff welcomes people all year round. This place is remarkable for its professional service. From the guests' point of view, prices are average. There is a charming atmosphere and nice decor at this spot. 4.6 is what this pizzeria received from the Google rating system.

Frequently mentioned in reviews

See allLess

Visitors' opinions on Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA

/ 613
Diane Weinberg Request content removal
Service was the WORST/SLOWEST that I have ever experienced anywhere (in >50 years of adulthood). The waitress was the most inattentive that I have ever seen. (This was in Aug. 2022.) Reservations for 10 (+ 3 very young children) on Sat. night. We arrived shortly ~7:00pm & were directed outside, to walk along the side of the building on a decline to a separate entrance (2 people were noticeably disabled & this was difficult for them - also, most were dressed in formal clerical garb). It was very noisy & one other group in this room was extremely loud. Seating was at one long table with hard wooden bench seats on one side and hard metal chairs on the other side. We waited a VERY long time for orders to even be taken. Beverages & bread were brought to the table and then the waitress effectively disappeared. Each of the 2 carafes of water held only enough for 2-1/2 glasses and we had to constantly ask for more water. After more than an hour, I finally flagged down the waitress, saying that my friend was gluten-intolerant & couldn't eat bread, that she hadn't eaten since 8:00am, to please bring her salad. We were hoping that this would prod her to bring all of the salads, but she served only the one. Shortly after that, the young kids' parents spoke up & a small pizza was brought out so that the kids could eat (this was already WAY after their bedtimes). We were not served our salads til after 8:30. When our salad plates were cleared, we asked the waitress about the delay & were told that "it was very busy." We pressed for an ETA about our entrees & she brushed us off. At 8:55pm, those of us at one end of the table agreed that, if we were still not served, we would simply walk out in 5 min. At 9:00pm, we were literally getting out of our seats when the first few entrees were brought out, so we stayed. My friend had ordered chicken ($19) and, while I continued to await my salmon ($25), she gave me some of her chicken (I returned the favor when my meal was served). After all of the entrees were served and half-finished, the waitress returned with the side-order veggies (broccoli & sliced potatoes - nothing else on the menu was available), each on a small bread plate. My salmon was tasty, but not outstanding and was a VERY small portion. All together (one person treated us), including drinks + tax - but not including tip (which NONE was deserved, but I'm sure was paid) - the bill was probably ~$300+. With this absolutely terrible service, I wouldn't go back there if we were comped for life. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 1 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1
Elizabeth Quinn Request content removal
Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Red Pizza, Double Crust White
M
Request content removal
They are not open anymore for dine in, we drove all the way there and there was a sign on the door no dine in anymore! Check that off the list of fine dining!
0 0 | Reply
Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian options
ClosedOpens at 11AM tomorrow
$$$$ Price range per person $11 - $30
Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA on map
© OpenStreetMap contributions
Get directions
443 S Main St
Old Forge, Pennsylvania, USA
Address
443 S Main St, Old Forge, Pennsylvania, USA
Features
Takeaway Outdoor seating Booking Сredit cards accepted Delivery Wheelchair accessible Parking TV
Opening hours
SundaySun 11AM-6PM
MondayMon 11AM-8PM
TuesdayTue 11AM-8PM
WednesdayWed 11AM-8PM
ThursdayThu 11AM-8PM
FridayFri 11AM-8PM
SaturdaySat 11AM-8PM

Tasty dishes in Old Forge

Restaurant features in Old Forge

Updated on: