Upload menu
Fast food, Vegetarian options
Open now 06:30 - 17:00
$$$$ Price range per person up to $10
100 Plaza Dr A, Buffalo
Bagel Jay's photo
Add a photo
Bagel Jay's photo
+ 17 photos Bagel Jay's photo
+ 16 photos Bagel Jay's photo
Bagel Jay's photo
+ 14 photos Bagel Jay's photo
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Get directions 100 Plaza Dr A
Buffalo, New York, USA

You can always enjoy perfectly cooked breakfast bagels, breakfast sandwiches and bagel sandwiches - a special offer of this restaurant. According to the visitors' opinions, waiters offer good macarons here. Delicious coffee is waiting for you at Bagel Jay's.

This place is well known for its great service and friendly staff, that is always ready to help you. Prices are found adequate here. 4 is how users rate this spot on Zomato.

Visitors' opinions on Bagel Jay's

/ 173
Add your opinion
I was soo excited to visit here. You see the commercial s and get so excited, loads of schmear...over flowing with meats and cheeses. Then you get the opportunity to go.... And it was like wat- wa. :( the people were great-ish. The 2 ladies i delt with were nice but tired. Like they really wanted to be elsewhere.Lol it was very clean nice atmosphere. Even the menu board had bagel sandwiches overloaded with meats and schmear. So we order, and sit down, they braught food out in a decent amount of time. We are on the edge of our seats with anticipation... Well my shoulders drop. I have pictures. I spent $8.95 for a bagel the size of my petit hand ( the palm). I expected a bagel the size of (at least) my brothers hand. He's 6+ tall. Engulfs my hand. And $2.95 for a MEDIUM drink. I didn't get chips and wasn't asked or offered a meal deal/lunch special. I saw that after we finished eating. Ok here's the review: decent food extremely overpriced. Extremely. I can say I went there. :)
We didn't feel there was anything special about it. The bagel nothing more than average , the same for the coffee , not a good value. Panera's bagels are far superior and the coffee is as well. Much better value in our opinion.
Best bagels in Buffalo hands down! Any time I'm in the mood for a bagel, Bagel Jay's is where you will find me. I've been coming to this location which is right near the neighborhood I grew up in for at least 15 years. In middle and high school, pepperoni pizza bagels were me and my brother's favorite for an after school snack. Nowadays, I am a huge fan of the nova lox bagel. It is one of their best. Their sausage, egg and cheese is also unequaled by any other place around. The bagels and other ingredients are always incredibly fresh. Daily soups are on point. A sesame bagel toasted, with a veggie or olive pimento schmear is also one of my favorites, and sometimes I will buy a few bagels to go with cream cheese when I am in the mood for bagels all week. The drive thru makes grabbing a bagel on the go, quick and easy. I highly recommend this place. I was happy that their new location on Main & Harlem opened up since that is a bit closer to where I live now. That location is good as well, but occasionally you will come across a subpar employee.
All opinions
Get directions
100 Plaza Dr A, Buffalo, New York, USA
Сredit cards accepted Delivery Outdoor seating Wi-Fi Takeaway Wheelchair accessible Parking
Opening hours
SundaySun 07:00-16:00
MondayMon 06:30-17:00
TuesdayTue 06:30-17:00
WednesdayWed 06:30-17:00
ThursdayThu 06:30-17:00
FridayFri 06:30-17:00
SaturdaySat 07:00-16:00

Popular collections including Bagel Jay's

See all
Updated on: