Top 5 restaurants in Cooperstown, october 2026

Norbu Restaurant

4.8 331 votes

$$$$

Indian

Mel's at 22

4.9 3566 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood

Bocca Osteria

4.8 2974 votes

$$$$

Italian, Wine bars

Toscana of Cooperstown

4.8 1173 votes

$$$$

Italian

Blue Mingo Grill

4.8 2306 votes

$$$$

American

Hawkeye Bar & Grill

4.8 2469 votes

$$$$

American, Fast food

Upstate Bar and Grill

4.9 3417 votes

$$$$

American, New American, Sandwiches

Tunnicliff Inn

4.2 739 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood, Steakhouses

1909

2.7 239 votes

$$$$

Seafood, Wine bars

The Otesaga Resort Hotel

4.8 1838 votes

$$$$

American

Cooperstown Mt.Fuji sushi restaurant

2.7 232 votes

$$$$

Sushi, Japanese, Steakhouses

Pit

3.5 59 votes

$$$$

American, Steakhouses

Doubleday Cafe

4.8 4042 votes

$$$$

American, Mexican

Pioneer Patio

4 971 votes

$$$$

American, German, Sandwiches

J & D's Wagon Wheel

4.8 780 votes

$$$$

American

Sal's Pizzeria of Cooperstown

4.8 1453 votes

$$$$

Pizza, Italian

Lake Front Motel

1.5 141 votes

$$$$

American

Sherman’s Tavern

4.8 81 votes

$$$$

American, New American

HardBall Café

2.1 562 votes

$$$$

American

Rusty Bison

2.1 611 votes

$$$$

Barbecue

Toscana of Cooperstown

4.8 1173 votes

$$$$

Italian

Pioneer Patio

4 971 votes

$$$$

American, German, Sandwiches

HardBall Café

2.1 562 votes

$$$$

American

Upstate Bar and Grill

4.9 3417 votes

$$$$

American, New American, Sandwiches

Mel's at 22

4.9 3566 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood

Norbu Restaurant

4.8 331 votes

$$$$

Indian

Schneider's Bakery

3.9 1100 votes

$$$$

Donuts

Doubleday Cafe

4.8 4042 votes

$$$$

American, Mexican

Bocca Osteria

4.8 2974 votes

$$$$

Italian, Wine bars

New York Pizzeria

4.8 1798 votes

$$$$

Pizza, Italian

Stagecoach Coffee

4.8 2328 votes

$$$$

American, International, Healthy food

Hawkeye Bar & Grill

4.8 2469 votes

$$$$

American, Fast food

Sal's Pizzeria of Cooperstown

4.8 1453 votes

$$$$

Pizza, Italian

Rusty Bison

2.1 611 votes

$$$$

Barbecue

Windy Blues

3.5 38 votes

$$$$

Pizza, Barbecue, American

Slices Pizzeria

3.1 94 votes

$$$$

Pizza

McDonald's

1.9 925 votes

$$$$

Fast food

The Busy Bee Mobile Cafe Fireside Grill

4 votes

$$$$

Caribbean

Nicoletta's Italian Cafe

3.1 1508 votes

$$$$

Italian

Depot Deli

1.2 24 votes

$$$$

Delis

Blue Mingo Grill

4.8 2306 votes

$$$$

American

Norbu Restaurant

4.8 331 votes

$$$$

Indian

Sal's Pizzeria of Cooperstown

4.8 1453 votes

$$$$

Pizza, Italian

Slices Pizzeria

3.1 94 votes

$$$$

Pizza

Cooper's Barn

3 467 votes

$$$$

Barbecue, Fast food

McDonald's

1.9 925 votes

$$$$

Fast food

Stagecoach Coffee

4.8 2328 votes

$$$$

American, International, Healthy food

Cooperstown Mt.Fuji sushi restaurant

2.7 232 votes

$$$$

Sushi, Japanese, Steakhouses

Natty Bumppo’s

1.3 53 votes

$$$$

New American, Fast food

Upstate Bar and Grill

4.9 3417 votes

$$$$

American, New American, Sandwiches

Mel's at 22

4.9 3566 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood

The Otesaga Resort Hotel

4.8 1838 votes

$$$$

American

New York Pizzeria

4.8 1798 votes

$$$$

Pizza, Italian

Pioneer Patio

4 971 votes

$$$$

American, German, Sandwiches

HardBall Café

2.1 562 votes

$$$$

American

Doubleday Cafe

4.8 4042 votes

$$$$

American, Mexican

Bocca Osteria

4.8 2974 votes

$$$$

Italian, Wine bars

Hawkeye Bar & Grill

4.8 2469 votes

$$$$

American, Fast food

Cooperstown Diner

4.8 2730 votes

$$$$

American

Schneider's Bakery

3.9 1100 votes

$$$$

Donuts

1909

2.7 239 votes

$$$$

Seafood, Wine bars

Mel's at 22

4.9 3566 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood