Upload menu
Open now 11:30 - 02:00
$$$$ Price range per person $11-30
2349 Millersport Hwy, Getzville
Elmo's photo
Add a photo
Elmo's photo
+ 17 photos Elmo's photo
+ 16 photos Elmo's photo
Elmo's photo
+ 14 photos Elmo's photo
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Get directions 2349 Millersport Hwy
Getzville, New York, USA

You can order mouthwatering buffalo wings, chicken wings and honey wings. Delicious draft beer is the most popular drinks of this bar. The cosy atmosphere of Elmo's makes visitors feel relaxed and have a nice time. The efficient staff welcomes guests all year round. Fast service is something clients appreciate here. You may be surprised by attractive prices at this place. Most people suppose that the decor here is homey. This spot has been rated by visitors and gained the 4 score on Yelp.

Visitors' opinions on Elmo's

/ 418
Add your opinion
Cajun wings are the great! Service always impeccable! Cozy and warm atmosphere! Love it here!
I went there for lunch and it was completely disgusting - my friend had wings and I ordered fingers- I thought they seemed kind of rubbery and a little undercooked- I wasn't going to say anything but my friend said her wings were not crispy and seemed undercooked as well.  We asked if they could please just cook them for a couple extra minutes- someone from the kitchen came out and walked towards us and literally said "is there something with you?" as he was walking out the door- my friend thought he was asking about our food, but he wasn't I heard what he said--- he went outside and came back in like 10 minutes later-- the waitress was nice and said there were 3 cooks in the kitchen because the regular "chef" was out--- well they only needed a deep fryer and no joke-- our food came , out about 30 minutes later-- and literally we were the ONLY PEOPLE IN THE ENTIRE RESTAURANT, BAR INCLUDED!!!! I really wanted to leave but my friend didn't because she goes there a couple times a month and  cant for the life me understand why-  All we asked for a few extra minutes--- again we sat in that dark, depressing, EMPTY, greasy place and had to wait for 30 minutes!!  it was petrified fried- super greasy-- but yet dried out-- totally gross, well they really showed us!!  I figured they were probably doing something gross to our food since almost right after we got it- all 3 cooks came out and were sitting at the bar watching the tv but glancing over at us-- we just got boxes, paid our bill for that shit food and left- I will never go back there again, nor will I ever advise many of my out of town guests to go there- I used to live nearby and went often, but its obviously nothing like it used to be or the place would not be empty during lunch - (which should have been my first clue)if it was still any good-- total shithole now
Hit up Elmo's with a few friends around 9 pm on a Friday and it was pretty packed. We were able to be seated right away however. At first impression I was nervous. It seemed a little "divey" and not the cleanest. But I heard the food was great so I wanted to give it a fair chance. Service was great. The guy waiting on us was fast and kept up with our requests and the rest of his tables (it was busy!) with ease. We ordered onion rings and had them come out first. They were fast! And seriously delicious. Portions were good too as you can see from the pic below. And the server gave us a whole bowl of ranch for dipping which pretty much made him my favorite person at that point. The guys I was with all had wings. My fiancé ordered 10 medium and he said they were good. Portions were good and he'd consider them a solid wing. Our friends enjoyed theirs as well. I ordered the chicken wrap but I wanted to try the Cajun chicken instead of plain grilled and they were able to do so for me. Wow was it delicious! The wrap was so good and the Cajun sauce was spicy. Good portion size too. Came with fries that I didn't even have room for because I was stuffed! Overall a solid dining experience. I took off one star simply because it definitely seemed like the place needed a good cleaning. There were some fruit flies flying around us as we ate and menus were sticky. When the dining room is dirty I always worry about what the kitchen looks like. Overall it's a decent place to get a good meal if you're looking for something non chain. Best for a group for a night out but due to the cleanliness issues I wouldn't make it a first choice.
All opinions
Get directions
2349 Millersport Hwy, Getzville, New York, USA
Takeaway Delivery No outdoor seating TV Wheelchair accessible Сredit cards accepted No Wi-Fi Parking No booking
Opening hours
SundaySun Closed
MondayMon 11:30-02:00
TuesdayTue 11:30-02:00
WednesdayWed 11:30-02:00
ThursdayThu 11:30-02:00
FridayFri 11:30-02:00
SaturdaySat 12:00-02:00
Updated on: