Open now 11:00 - 22:00
$$$$ Price range per person up to $10
5526 Main St #6702, Williamsville
Muscarella's Pizza photo
Add a photo
Muscarella's Pizza photo
+ 17 photos Muscarella's Pizza photo
+ 16 photos Muscarella's Pizza photo
Muscarella's Pizza photo
+ 14 photos Muscarella's Pizza photo
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Get directions 5526 Main St #6702
Williamsville, New York, USA

Saints Peter & Paul Church is what you should see after having a meal at Muscarella's Pizza. Try good Pepperoni, chicken fingers and pies. At this pizzeria, you can order a takeout. The positive aspect of Muscarella's Pizza is that the staff is pleasant. If you want to enjoy fabulous service, you should go to this place. From the visitors' viewpoint, prices are fair. But this spot has been rated below average by Zomato reviewers.

Visitors' opinions on Muscarella's Pizza

/ 133
Add your opinion
Best pizza in the village!
This place has always been a favorite since it opened, and it continued to maintain it's excellent standards throughout the years, however, sadly yesterday was one of my first bad experiences. I ordered a regular cheeseburger with letteus and tomato, which seemed to be "sabataged" by I'm assuming a disgruntled employee. On top of the cheese was about 1/2 to nearly a full teaspoon of salt & pepper mix, which for a single burger is quite a lot. I ate what I could and discarded the rest that was beyond inedible, and ate the rest of my food which turned out just fine. I don't blame management for this or Muscarella's as a whole, just the cook that made my burger, that was not cool.
I just posted this on facebook & twitter via instagram: Big shout out to Muscarella's Pizza in Williamsville! Not only is their food delicious, but their staff always go above and beyond for their customers! I ordered food for delivery, when we usually do pick up when we order. They forgot part of the order. Instead of passing the blame or ignoring the fact, they apologized, informed me of the problem, and that someone will bring it right over as soon as it's ready. Then, when it arrived, they again apologized profusely, and asked how the rest of the food was. It's incredibly refreshing knowing that there is still great #customerservice out there!
All opinions
Get directions
5526 Main St #6702, Williamsville, New York, USA
Delivery Takeaway Сredit cards accepted No booking No outdoor seating No Wi-Fi Parking No TV Wheelchair accessible
Opening hours
SundaySun 11:00-22:00
MondayMon 11:00-22:00
TuesdayTue 11:00-22:00
WednesdayWed 11:00-22:00
ThursdayThu 11:00-22:00
FridayFri 11:00-22:00
SaturdaySat 11:00-22:00

Popular collections including Muscarella's Pizza

See all
Updated on: