Italian, Seafood, Steakhouses, Vegetarian options
ClosedOpens at 16:00
$$$$ Price range per person $11-30
1075 Duval St, Key West
New York Pasta Garden photo
Add a photo
New York Pasta Garden photo
+ 17 photos New York Pasta Garden photo
+ 16 photos New York Pasta Garden photo
New York Pasta Garden photo
+ 14 photos New York Pasta Garden photo
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Get directions 1075 Duval St
Key West, Florida, USA

If you happen to be near Tennessee Williams Key West Exhibit, you can visit this steakhouse. Taste Italian cuisine here. Have good shrimp scampi, Italian pasta and artichoke appetizers at New York Pasta Garden when you happen to be near it. A lot of guests point out that waiters serve tasty tiramisu, key lime pie and cannolis here. You will be offered delicious marsala, house wine or chianti. Drink the great cappuccino offered here.

It's easy to find this place due to its convenient location. A number of reviewers consider the staff terrific. If you want to experience fabulous service, you should go to this spot. Prices are found affordable here. You will appreciate the cute decor and enjoyable atmosphere of this steakhouse. But the rating of New York Pasta Garden isn't high on Zomato.

Visitors' opinions on New York Pasta Garden

/ 715
Add your opinion
Service was great! Thank you Vlad, our server. And... if you're just looking for good Italian for a good price, this is the spot! Seafood options look great, a little pricey. Great atmosphere. Will 100% go back again, next trip. No reso needed.
We were there over Christmas so I thought pasta dinner on Christmas night would be nice.   Both the service and food were sub par and very disappointing.   First off, there were birds all over the place.  I love birds, but kind of weird in a restaurant.  It would have been nice to hear a story of why they were there.   The server was off.  At first, he talked at us but then we hardly ever saw him.    He put the garlic knots at our table without telling us about them.   I ordered veal picatta which was gross.  It looked like it was thrown together.  I've made better at home.  Hubs had the spaghetti and meatballs which were decent.   We really weren't checked on and we weren't finished eating when the check was slammed on our table.  No asking if we wanted coffee or dessert.   It seems he was too interested in feeding himself .... we had been seated outside and wanted to see what the inside looked like.   Our waiter was sitting there eating dinner.   Not saying he's not allowed to eat, but our service suffered so he could sit down.  Very very disappointed especially for a special holiday meal.
We are visiting Key West and had dinner at The New York Pasta Garden. This is the first time we ate such authentic and delicious Italian food. We ordered the Pasta Primavera, Alfredo pasta and Baked Toretellini. We had Key Lime Pie and Tiramisu for dessert. The staff is friendly and the ambience is awesome. This place is a must eat when you visit Key West.
All opinions
Get directions
1075 Duval St, Key West, Florida, USA
Outdoor seating Booking Сredit cards accepted Delivery Wi-Fi Takeaway Parking Wheelchair accessible No TV
Opening hours
SundaySun 16:00-23:00
MondayMon 16:00-23:00
TuesdayTue 16:00-23:00
WednesdayWed 16:00-23:00
ThursdayThu 16:00-23:00
FridayFri 16:00-23:00
SaturdaySat 16:00-23:00

Popular collections including New York Pasta Garden

See all
Updated on: