New York Pasta Garden

/ Restaurant, Seafood
#41 of 741 places to eat in Key West
Open now 16:00 - 23:00
Italian, Seafood, Steakhouses, Vegetarian options
$$$$ Average price: $11-30
Add a photo
Add your opinion
New York Pasta Garden photo
Add a photo
New York Pasta Garden photo
+ 97 photos New York Pasta Garden photo
+ 96 photos New York Pasta Garden photo
New York Pasta Garden photo
+ 94 photos New York Pasta Garden photo
1075 Duval St
Key West, Florida, USA
Get directions

Guests reserve a table for tasty dishes here and enjoy the sights of Tennessee Williams Key West Exhibit. Italian cuisine is recommended to degust at this steakhouse. The truth is that you will really like tasty shrimp scampi, artichoke appetizers and caprese salads. That's a nice idea to order good key lime pie, tiramisu and cannolis.

The wine list is extensive, every visitor can find something that suits their taste. At New York Pasta Garden, clients may order great cappuccino. The cool staff works hard, stays positive and makes this place great. Fabulous service is something that people note in their comments. You may be surprised by low prices at this place. The cute decor and nice atmosphere let visitors feel relaxed here. But zomato users haven't given this spot a high rating.

Visitors' opinions

/ 685
Add your opinion
It a delightful place at Duval square. Gina, our waitress was attentive and gracious. Every single dish was deliciously made. The only reason why I didn't give it five star is because my lasagna mixture of sauce and ground beef pieces were huge. I literally tried to remove it, but they were too big; too many.
Worst filet mignon ever. Burnt and not tender. No flavor. The only redeeming quality about this place is nice environment. Also, they automatically charged 20% tip for our party of 4.
BEST RESTAURANT IN THE KEYS! I'm not joking. The staff was so pleasant and welcoming. The location of the restaurant is so cute and they have 4+ parrots outside the restaurant just chilling out. The menu has a large selection so perfect for picky eaters! It's so hard to explain how perfect the food was! Go try for yourself. You won't regret it !
All opinions
1075 Duval St, Key West, Florida, USA
Сredit cards accepted Outdoor seating Wi-Fi Booking Takeaway Delivery Parking Wheelchair accessible
Opening hours
SundaySun 16:00-23:00
MondayMon 16:00-23:00
TuesdayTue 16:00-23:00
WednesdayWed 16:00-23:00
ThursdayThu 16:00-23:00
FridayFri 16:00-23:00
SaturdaySat 16:00-23:00

Popular collections including New York Pasta Garden

See all
Updated on: