Italian, Seafood, Steakhouses, Vegetarian options
ClosedOpens at 4PM
$$$$ Price range per person $11 - $28
1075 Duval St, Key West
Add a photo
21 photos
Try out pizza at New York Pasta Garden
Food at New York Pasta Garden
Meals at New York Pasta Garden
Food at New York Pasta Garden
Look at the pic of New York Pasta Garden
Here's a pic of New York Pasta Garden
Check out how New York Pasta Garden looks inside
Add a photo
Add your opinion
New York Pasta Garden on map
© OpenStreetMap contributions
Get directions 1075 Duval St
Key West, Florida, USA

Clients book a table for tasty meals here and enjoy the sights of Tennessee Williams Key West Exhibit. Italian cuisine provides flavorsome food at this steakhouse. Offering tasty shrimp scampi, artichoke appetizers and parmo is the hallmark of New York Pasta Garden. You will be offered good tiramisu, key lime pie and cannolis. It's a must to order delicious marsala, limoncello or house wine while coming to this place. As a number of reviewers say, cappuccino is really great.

The homely atmosphere of this spot allows guests to relax after a hard working day. The creative staff works hard, stays positive and makes this place great. Nice service is something that visitors highlight in their reviews. You will pay reasonable prices for dishes. It is noteworthy that decor is beautiful. Google users who visited this steakhouse state that the most suitable mark is 4.5.

Visitors' opinions on New York Pasta Garden

/ 956
Add your opinion
Chloe W.
I got the lobster ravioli and their Sauvignon blanc and was a nice pair. Very good quality food with kind staff and great ambiance outdoors. Being in Duval square puts this in a great location! The music was so nice and just overall a pleasant time. Was a little pricey but DEFINITELY worth it :) lots of options with huge portions!
Gregg W.
A local recommended the New York Pasta Garden and we are so pleased we called in for dinner! Our waiter Fletcher was amazing. He provided spot on menu selection advice and ensured we wanted for nothing. The seafood pasta menu options are plentiful and so flavorful. Our party of five all enjoyed our dinning experience and will definitely return. Ask for Fletcher, he will make sure you have an amazing dinning experience!
Derek Matthews
Beyond my expectations. I was a little hesitant to go to a pasta place being on vacation so close to the Caribbean, but so glad we did. The service was great, we got a free starter, and the food was some of the best Italian food I've had. My entire party was so happy with what they ordered and we ate until we were stuffed!
All opinions
Get directions
1075 Duval St, Key West, Florida, USA
Outdoor seating Сredit cards accepted Wi-Fi Booking Delivery Takeaway Parking Wheelchair accessible
Opening hours
SundaySun 4PM-11PM
MondayMon 4PM-11PM
TuesdayTue 4PM-11PM
WednesdayWed 4PM-11PM
ThursdayThu 4PM-11PM
FridayFri 4PM-11PM
SaturdaySat 4PM-11PM
Updated on: