Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian options
Closed now
$$$$ Price range per person $11-30
2872 Delaware Ave, Kenmore
Jay's Artisan Pizzeria photo
Add a photo
Jay's Artisan Pizzeria photo
+ 17 photos Jay's Artisan Pizzeria photo
+ 16 photos Jay's Artisan Pizzeria photo
Jay's Artisan Pizzeria photo
+ 14 photos Jay's Artisan Pizzeria photo
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Get directions 2872 Delaware Ave
Kenmore, New York, USA

This pizzeria is known for providing Italian cuisine. The unique characteristic of Jay's Artisan Pizzeria is serving nicely cooked neapolitan pizza, pies and Pepperoni. You will hardly forget good beer, wine or margaritas that you can drink. Come to this place for delicious americano.

Food delivery is a big advantage of this spot. A number of reviewers mark that the staff is cute at this place. If you want to enjoy fabulous service, you should go to this pizzeria. Based on the guests' opinions, prices are attractive. From the visitors' point of view, the atmosphere is cozy. The discussions on Jay's Artisan Pizzeria have led to 4.5 Yelp-branded stars for this place.

Best in the city

Great service
Romantic atmosphere

Visitors' opinions on Jay's Artisan Pizzeria

/ 321
Add your opinion
Nice place for a quick bite to eat. My pizza was good even though the dough was not fully done and toppings not fully cooked. I would be willing to give it another shot as I feel like the quality of ingredients are there. They also serve beer and wine which is nice. The prices are a little high for the size but I prefer quality over quantity.
Absolutely fabulous thin crust pizza cooked in a brick oven! The dough is so good as well , as I usually don’t eat the ends of the pizza crust . But with this pizza I ate the whole slice !
I was completely blown away to find out that there is an authentic Neapolitan pizzeria here in Western New York. Upon arriving at Jay's, I was greeted and given some great pointers on which pizzas to get. Of course I had to get a traditional margarita, but then the cashier suggested that I try the "Amanda" pizza as well. I was completely blown away by the quality and speed at which I received my food. Despite having a completely packed dining room (obviously a popular spot to be so full on a Wednesday night), I received my two pizzas quicker than I could even finish a conversation with other fellow pizza lovers. Needless to say, there was a reason why this place was so packed. The margarita pizza was hands down one of the best margaritas that I've ever had, including the couple of places that I visited while traveling through Italy. The Amanda pizza was amazing and I've never had another pizza quite like it. The margarita is definitely the go-to classic, but I think I've found my new personal favorite in the "Amanda" pizza from Jay's Artisan Pizzeria. I heard that they also do Detroit style pizza pop-ups, but sell out of those pretty quick every time so I am hoping to make it in for one of those in the near future. Amazing food, quick service, and super friendly/accommodating staff. I'd give them more than 5 stars if I could! Keep up the great work guys!
All opinions
Get directions
2872 Delaware Ave, Kenmore, New York, USA
Сredit cards accepted Takeaway No delivery No outdoor seating Wi-Fi Parking No booking TV
Opening hours
SundaySun Closed
MondayMon Closed
TuesdayTue 16:00-21:00
WednesdayWed 16:00-21:00
ThursdayThu 16:00-21:00
FridayFri 16:00-21:00
SaturdaySat 12:00-21:00

Popular collections including Jay's Artisan Pizzeria

See all
Updated on: