Top Pizzerias in Orangeville for Authentic Pizza Lovers

This place matches all criteria and is highly praised for its pizza. Visitors rave about the taste, crust, and quality of the pies, considering it the best in town. The restaurant is noted for excellent service and friendly owners. Customers appreciate the variety of deals, such as 2-for-1 pizzas, and consistently find the food delicious.

Location:

50 4th Ave

Average price:

$$$$ (Price range per person up to CAD 14)

Customers are happy with the delicious dairy-free pizza, catering to those with food allergies. They also commend the helpful staff and fast service. There are mixed reviews about the quality of food, but many enjoy their meals there. Customer service is notably good, especially towards those with dietary needs.

Location:

88 First St

Average price:

$$$$ (Price range per person CAD 14 - CAD 34)

Highly praised for amazing pizza and quick, friendly service. Patrons enjoy various dishes like Arancini, Caprese salad, and Margherita pizza. Despite minor service hiccups, most find the quality of the food outstanding and the overall experience satisfying.

Location:

111 Broadway

Average price:

$$$$ (Price range per person CAD 14 - CAD 34)

Customers enjoy great pizza and excellent service, with some negative feedback about mistakes in orders. The taste and quality of the food are highly valued. Many consider it their go-to pizza place in Orangeville, despite mixed reviews on service.

Location:

475 489 Broadway #10

Average price:

$$$$ (Price range per person CAD 11 - CAD 30)

Visitors appreciate the pizza and friendly staff. However, some reviews indicate inconsistent quality. The restaurant is often praised for its fantastic pizza and great service, making it a favorite for many.

Location:

47 Broadway

Average price:

$$$$ (Price range per person up to CAD 14)

This restaurant has mixed reviews, with some customers praising the pizza quality while others complain about poor service and slow delivery. Despite this, the pizza is often described as legit and a favorite for many.

Location:

283 Broadway

Average price:

$$$$ (Price range per person up to CAD 14)

Reviews highlight good pizza and other side dishes, like cheesy bread. Some complaints about service and cold pizza, but generally a positive experience.

Location:

520 Riddell Rd

Average price:

$$$$ (Price range per person up to CAD 14)

Noted for fresh ingredients and generous toppings, this place offers a variety of pizza options that are well-liked by customers. Although pricier than some others, the quality and quick service are praised.

Location:

75 Alder St

Customers generally find the pizza to be excellent, consistent and flavorful. Some negative experiences with service and occasional food quality issues, but overall positive reviews for taste and value.

Location:

50 Rolling Hills Dr

Average price:

$$$$ (Price range per person up to CAD 14)

Highly praised for authentic Italian-inspired dishes, this place offers fresh, high-quality ingredients. Some reviews mention cold pizza on certain occasions but generally a positive dining experience.

Location:

100 Broadway

Average price:

$$$$ (Price range per person CAD 14 - CAD 34)