Add a photo
37 photos
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Nicely cooked pies have a nice taste. Good gelato is so delicious here that it will certainly become one of your favorite dishes. This confectionary restaurant offers the nice service to its clients.
Frequently mentioned in reviews
Visitors' opinions on Piece of Cake
/ 15
Add your opinion
C
Request content removal
Charlene T.
a year ago on Yelp
Great selection and great service...I highly recommend the sampler, everyone loved it...will be buying again soon!
M
Request content removal
Missy B.
a year ago on Yelp
A decade ago I had a co-worker that told me about this place. She said it was the best place for ice cream. I finally went out and found the place last year when the pandemic started and all the grocery stores were sold out of ice cream. First thing I took notice of when I got there is the people that work here are super friendly. (And were friendly still each time I came back) Not lying, it's the best ice cream I've ever had. I bought my mother's birthday ice cream pie (the one with the pecans) to her birthday dinner party. At first everyone laughed at me when I told them it's the best but they stopped laughing and agreed with me after they'd tried it. My mother had five birthday cakes that night and the pecan pie I brought was the only one finished at the end of the night. I keep coming back here, the ice creams, gelatos and tartufos are the best.
M
Request content removal
Mr. O.
3 years ago on Yelp
Want an adventure? Circle the Rahway Knights of Columbus hall, searching for something that appears to sell ice cream. Find a light green house with the Piece of Cake sign next to it, figure the house must be the place! Park, go up to the house and lift your hand to knock before realizing No, the location you're looking for is actually the commercial building behind the house, accessible through an alley. This is where it gets fun. When you go into the shop, you're faced with a wall containing a 2 way mirror. Next to the mirror is a door secured with a biometric fingerprint lock. You feel like you're in FBI custody, if the FBI had pictures of ice cream hanging on the walls. You stand there, staring at yourself in the mirror with your hat and your big winter coat and your face mask and you feel like a fugitive, or like you're lost. The door opens a crack and a man's voice tells you to wait. You nod obediently. What choice do you have? Finally from behind the secure door comes a man with a Lynyrd Skynyrd t shirt, a big silver crucifix on a chain, and, yes, a face mask. The owner, James! James was unexpectedly friendly. We drove 45 minutes from our home to get there and he knew the names of local independent ice cream shops in our town. We got the sampler pie and served it to guests the next day. You should have heard their gasps when we opened the box. The guests were adults but it took them so long to decide on their flavors, like children. It was cute. They ended up eating a lot of it and raving about it. But we still have plenty left to eat ourselves this week. :-) You will have a hard time buying another ice cream chain store cake after this. We will be back.
All opinions
ClosedOpens at 7AM tomorrow
$$$$
Price range per person $10 - $25
© OpenStreetMap
contributions
Address
62 W Inman Ave, Rahway, New Jersey, USA, 07065-2916
Features
Takeaway
Parking
Opening hours
| SundaySun | Closed |
| MondayMon | Closed |
| TuesdayTue | 7AM-4PM |
| WednesdayWed | 7AM-4PM |
| ThursdayThu | 7AM-4PM |
| FridayFri | 7AM-4PM |
| SaturdaySat | 7AM-2PM |
Website
Instagram
@pieceofcake_icecream
