Top 7 restaurants in Sanibel, october 2026

Timbers Restaurant

5 4458 votes

$$$$

Seafood, Sushi, Grill

Gramma Dot's Restaurant

5 5787 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American

Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille

5 18939 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American, Grill, Caribbean

Sundial Beach Resort & Spa

4.9 3038 votes

$$$$

Japanese, Sushi, Steakhouses

Wickies Lighthouse Restaurant

4.9 1105 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood

The Bubble Room Restaurant

5 11707 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood

Traders Restaurant on Sanibel

4.9 4389 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American, Cocktail bars

MudBugs Cajun Kitchen

4.9 4993 votes

$$$$

Cajun, Seafood, Creole, Grill, Sandwiches

Keylime Bistro

4.9 6861 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American

RC Otter's Island Eats

4.9 4058 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American

Bleu Rendezvous French Bistro

4.8 1193 votes

$$$$

French, Seafood, Steakhouses, Wine bars

BRGR Kitchen +Bar

4.8 384 votes

$$$$

Fast food, American, Cocktail bars, Salads

Cielo Restaurant

4.8 4095 votes

$$$$

Seafood, New American, Mediterranean, American

Blue Giraffe Island Bar and Grill

4.9 5735 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood, Grill

Tutti Pazzi Italian Kitchen

4.8 973 votes

$$$$

Italian, Pizza, Seafood

Rosalita's Cantina Sanibel

4.9 746 votes

$$$$

Mexican

Thistle Lodge Beachfront Restaurant

4.3 4467 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American, New American, Fusion

Crow's Nest Steakhouse

3.5 984 votes

$$$$

Seafood, Steakhouses, American, Cocktail bars

Lazy Flamingo

4.8 3159 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American

Jerry's Café

3.9 2191 votes

$$$$

American

Great White Grill

4.8 1328 votes

$$$$

Pizza, American

Island Pizza Restaurant

4.4 3039 votes

$$$$

Pizza, Italian

The Shack of Sanibel

4.8 714 votes

$$$$

Dessert, Sandwiches

Doc Ford's Rum Bar & Grille

5 18939 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American, Grill, Caribbean

Keylime Bistro

4.9 6861 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American

Traders Restaurant on Sanibel

4.9 4389 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American, Cocktail bars

RC Otter's Island Eats

4.9 4058 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American

Jerry's Foods

4.9 1712 votes

$$$$

Delis

Over Easy Cafe

4.9 7670 votes

$$$$

American

New

Island Panda

4.8 49 votes

$$$$

Sushi

Jerry's Café

3.9 2191 votes

$$$$

American

Crow's Nest Steakhouse

3.5 984 votes

$$$$

Seafood, Steakhouses, American, Cocktail bars

7-Eleven

3 32 votes

$$$$

Pizza

The Bubble Room Restaurant

5 11707 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood

Lighthouse Cafe of Sanibel Island

5 6098 votes

$$$$

American

Timbers Restaurant

5 4458 votes

$$$$

Seafood, Sushi, Grill

Sanibel Café

5 2626 votes

$$$$

American

New

Scooters Pizza Kitchen

5 298 votes

$$$$

Pizza

Blue Giraffe Island Bar and Grill

4.9 5735 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood, Grill

Bleu Rendezvous French Bistro

4.8 1193 votes

$$$$

French, Seafood, Steakhouses, Wine bars

Island Pizza Restaurant

4.4 3039 votes

$$$$

Pizza, Italian

New

Scooters Pizza Kitchen

5 298 votes

$$$$

Pizza

The Shack of Sanibel

4.8 714 votes

$$$$

Dessert, Sandwiches

The Bel Bagels & Deli

4.8 107 votes

$$$$

Wickies Lighthouse Restaurant

4.9 1105 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood

The Magic Bus Ice Cream & Caffeine

4.8 321 votes

$$$$

The Sanibel Sprout Cafe

4.8 826 votes

$$$$

Vegan

Pinocchio's Original Italian Ice Cream

4.8 1052 votes

$$$$

Dessert

New

Island Panda

4.8 49 votes

$$$$

Sushi

Bailey's General Store

4.2 754 votes

Delis

Jerry's Café

3.9 2191 votes

$$$$

American

Huxters Market & Deli

3 258 votes

$$$$

Delis

7-Eleven

2.9 56 votes

$$$$

Pizza

The Bubble Room Restaurant

5 11707 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood

Keylime Bistro

4.9 6861 votes

$$$$

Seafood, American

Blue Giraffe Island Bar and Grill

4.9 5735 votes

$$$$

American, Seafood, Grill

Over Easy Cafe

4.9 7670 votes

$$$$

American

Rosalita's Cantina Sanibel

4.9 746 votes

$$$$

Mexican

The Original Cheeburger Cheeburger

4.8 1877 votes

$$$$

Grill

Dante's Italian Kitchen

4.8 1123 votes

$$$$

Italian, Pizza, American

Timbers Restaurant

5 4458 votes

$$$$

Seafood, Sushi, Grill