No info on opening hours
$$$$ Price range per person $61
59 Star Island Rd, Montauk
Star Island Grill photo
Add a photo
Star Island Grill photo
+ 18 photos Star Island Grill photo
+ 17 photos Star Island Grill photo
Star Island Grill photo
+ 15 photos Star Island Grill photo
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Get directions 59 Star Island Rd, 11954
Montauk, New York, USA
The Star Island Grill, featuring casual dining overlooking the Montauk Harbor, opens in early May, Thursday-Sunday, until Memorial Day. From Memorial Day through Labor Day, the restaurant is open 7 days a week for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. After Labor Day, the Star Island Grill is open from Thursday-Sunday until October 31st. Call (631) 668-5052 for questions about days and hours.

Best in the city

Club

Visitors' opinions on Star Island Grill

/ 63
Add your opinion
Great food. Great service beautiful location. Perfect
Excellent food! Try the mussels. Staff are friendly and prices are decent for the area! Pretty views of the dock and the drinks are delicious and fairly priced. You won’t be disappointed!
BREAKING NEWS: Star Island Grill, located on the premises of Star Island Yacht Club, has been hitching onto a Montauk trend called "You hook em, we cook em." The trend was started many years ago by the Chinese restaurant Wok n' Roll, which was also located in Montauk, until it closed down last year. I've been looking for a new place to escape for a good meal since then, until I found out that Star Island grill began cooking people's fish. I am an avid fisherman, and after a long day of striped bass fishing, brought my catch here for dinner. They cooked it 6 different ways: Panko, Tempura, Parmesan, Francaise, Italian Parmesan, and even General Tso's. The food was AMAZING. Best General Tso's I've had in years. On my way out, I tipped the cook, Tom, a few dollars, for his unbelievable work. This restaurant is a diamond in the middle of Lake Montauk. I'm sure it will become famous, and I expect it to be PACKED in the near future.
All opinions
Get directions
Address
59 Star Island Rd, Montauk, New York, USA, 11954
Features
Outdoor seating Takeaway Сredit cards accepted No delivery No Wi-Fi No booking TV
Verified by the owner

Popular collections including Star Island Grill

See all
Updated on: