The Cider Mill

Name: The Cider Mill
Address: 4221 Fay Rd, Syracuse, New York, USA
Telephone: +13154870647
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.7

#3 of 986 restaurants in Syracuse

#10 of 202 seafood restaurants in Syracuse

#42 of 397 pubs & bars in Syracuse

#3 of 73 steak restaurants in Syracuse

Add a photo

27 photos

Check out how The Cider Mill looks inside

Add a photo

Add your opinion

Make a reservation

You can have nicely cooked chicken leg, lamb shanks and soft-shell crabs at this confectionary restaurant. Try good cinnamon donuts, crème brûlée and Scones. Most likely, you'll come back to The Cider Mill later to degust delicious cider, wine or draft beer. After a long working week, you can taste great coffee.

This place is famous for its great service and friendly staff, that is always ready to help you. Pay reasonable prices for eating at this spot. The divine decor and calm atmosphere let guests feel relaxed here. As for the Google rating, this confectionary restaurant received 4.7.

Recommended by Restaurant Guru

Frequenty mentioned in reviews

wine list dinner cosy atmosphere birthday party

meat cheese poultry chicken lamb seafood poutine fish crabs chicken leg

See allLess

Ratings of The Cider Mill

Yelp

149

Foursquare

Not rated yet

Google

383

Trip

146

Facebook

4.9

284

Visitors' opinions on The Cider Mill

/ 605

Search visitors’ opinions

Add your opinion

Eve Neider N.

5 days ago on Yelp Request content removal

This is a hidden gem right outside the city of Syracuse! It is set back on backroads where you can take in the beautiful greenery of upstate NY. Inside it is very cozy and comforting. Our waitress was slow with the water, but made up for it with her fabulous, friendly service! The homemade bread served with olive oil is to die for, sad you get charged if you order more, but I understand. We ordered the hummus and Brussel sprouts for apps. the pita was perfectly warm with a nice grill on the outside and soft on the inside, best pita ever! The Brussel sprouts had me asking the waiter for the recipe they were so good! My mom and I ordered the scallops with crab and lobster risotto special, which was perfectly cooked all around which is hard to do with scallops and risotto. They were generous with the portion and the amount of crab and lobster chunks in the risotto. My dad got the chicken which he really liked too. We ended it with dessert of course: apple donut and flourless chocolate cake. The chocolate cake was alright, the raspberry sorbet on too saved it because it was kind of too chocolatey and a little dry. The apple donut was warm and not too dense, and the ice cream complemented it very well. It was beautiful looking and was the sweet ending we needed for the meal!

Cameron R.

14 days ago on Yelp Request content removal

The Cider Mill has a great atmosphere and the food is superb! The porkchop is especially delicious and the applesauce it's paired with goes so well with the rest of the meal. The service was also prompt despite it being a pretty busy night.

Russ Bartlett

15 days ago on Google Request content removal

Excellent. It’s expensive but worth the cost. Service was good and the food was excellent and well presented. The bread and dipping oil was some of the best I ever had.

Response from the owner

15 days ago

Thank you, Russ!

All opinions

Order via mobilebytes.com

+1 315-487-0647

American, New American, Dessert, Salads, Vegetarian options

ClosedOpens at 5PM

$$$$ Price range per person $10 - $25