Upload menu
Mexican, Latin American, Vegetarian options
ClosedOpens at 11:30
$$$$ Price range per person $11-30
251 W 50th St, New York City
Toloache photo
Add a photo
Toloache photo
+ 17 photos Toloache photo
+ 16 photos Toloache photo
Toloache photo
+ 14 photos Toloache photo
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Get directions 251 W 50th St
New York City, New York, USA

Visitors enjoy the sights of Times Square Church and book a table for nice dishes here. If you are fond of Mexican cuisine, visit this restaurant. Perfectly cooked brisket tacos, garlic shrimps and chips and guacamole are among the dishes to be tried at Toloache. Taste good churros, chocolate flans and chocolate cakes. Here you can order delicious margaritas, tequila or red sangria. This place has great cafe de olla, fresh juices or mexican coffee among its drinks.

A homely atmosphere and beautiful interior make this spot so good. The staff is said to be attentive here. The fabulous service is a great benefit of this restaurant. Attractive prices are what you will pay for your meal. Frommer's experts marked Toloache 2 stars, so it's worth visiting.

Visitors' opinions on Toloache

/ 1511
Add your opinion
Took the family to Toloache for Christmas dinner and it was a wonderful experience.   Staff was very friendly and attentive.  Restaurant was clean and well maintained while being very busy.  I have no complaints on our experience and we look forward to going again.   Food quality was great.  The best Mexican food we have had in a long time.   Definitely get: the guacamole with the pomegranate The grasshopper tacos The bone marrow tacos The crepe cake dessert.
Toloache is what I would call the dictionary definition of a tourist trap. We went there for dinner during the holidays and the whole experience was underwhelming. The place was packed and we had to wait 15 mins to be seated even though we had a reservation. Even after being seated, it was a while before our waiteress came by and took our order. However, apart from the initial wait, the service was decent. Coming to the food and drinks, we ordered guacamole, chicken tacos and truffle quesadilla and jalapeno cucumber margaritas. The margaritas were good. The guacamole was just ok, it was missing something but I couldn't really figure out what. The chicken tacos and quesadillas tasted decent but the portion size was unbelievably small! At the end of the meal, we were still kind of hungry. I wouldn't go back here because for the money spent here I could have had much better (and more) Mexican food at many other restaurants in the city.
I do 3 because I am conflicted here. The food is GOOD!So let me say this first. However the portions are SMALL. I have never in my life had a quesadilla that small. Its as big as a coffee cup saucer. My wife had two tacos. Again she REALLY LOVED them. But then again they are like over $8 per taco and regular sized. So you really need two apatizers of $16-$18 to have a meal. To me that makes it pricey. Personnel is hard working kind and good. The place itself crazy busy. Pretty much in the tourist trap zone unfortunately. (But hey good 4 business).
All opinions
Get directions
Address
251 W 50th St, New York City, New York, USA
Features
Delivery Takeaway Booking Сredit cards accepted TV Wheelchair accessible Wi-Fi Parking
Opening hours
SundaySun 11:30-22:00
MondayMon 11:30-22:00
TuesdayTue 11:30-23:00
WednesdayWed 11:30-23:00
ThursdayThu 11:30-23:00
FridayFri 11:30-00:00
SaturdaySat 11:30-00:00

Food guides for travelers

Updated on: