The menu items below highlight top-rated and popular dishes based on real customer reviews for reference only, and may not accurately reflect the current restaurant offerings.
Reviews indicate that the price/quality ratio is generally good, with some exceptions. Several dishes were highly praised, but there were also complaints about certain items being overpriced or of low quality.
Chicken Michael
- highly recommended by reviewers.
Oriental Beef Tips
- another popular choice among customers.
Grouper fillets
- served in a delicious batter, these are a must-try.
Street Tacos
- highly recommended for their taste and quality beyond typical bar food.
Blue Burger with Onion Rings
- a solid choice, especially if you're watching a game.
Ahi Tacos
- considered a better option than the pork tacos due to the tenderness of the meat.
Grouper Basket with Homemade Tartar
- highly praised by reviewers.
Key West Grouper
- described as the best meal one reviewer had during their week-long stay on Marco Island.
Captain Burger
- comes with crunchy onion ring, crumbled blue cheese, and sautéed mushrooms. A hit among Spanish-speaking customers.
Beach Burger
- traditional burger with added Provolone cheese, highly enjoyed by customers.
Tipsy Golfer
- a popular drink choice.
Taco Salad with Blackened Chicken
- a personal favorite of one reviewer.
Blazin' Shrimp Appetizer
- a good, saucy starter.
Key West Grouper with Shrimp and Crabmeat Stuffing
- a heavy but flavorful dish, served with a side of steamed vegetables.
