Find best restaurants! For business
Search
Where:

Restaurants in Bay Shore

Roadtrip

Roadtrip

5 1261 votes
$$$$
American, Cocktail bars, Salads
KPOT Korean BBQ & Hot Pot

KPOT Korean BBQ & Hot Pot

5 1092 votes
$$$$
Korean, Barbecue
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

4.9 6051 votes
$$$$
American, Seafood
Pecado Mexican

Pecado Mexican

4.9 1886 votes
$$$$
Mexican, Cocktail bars
The Lakehouse

The Lakehouse

4.8 6411 votes
$$$$
New American, Seafood, American
Nicky’s on the Bay

Nicky’s on the Bay

4.9 2526 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American
Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

4.8 1453 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi
Salt & Barrel

Salt & Barrel

4.8 4987 votes
$$$$
Seafood, New American, Cocktail bars
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

4.9 2680 votes
$$$$
Italian, Soups, Seafood, Mediterranean, Gluten-free, Wine bars, Salads
Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

4.8 1076 votes
$$$$
Italian, Cocktail bars, Wine bars
Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

4.8 1217 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Cocktail bars
Galanga

Galanga

4.8 635 votes
$$$$
Thai, Asian
Butera's - Bay Shore

Butera's - Bay Shore

4.8 1873 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza
Magnolias

Magnolias

4.8 106 votes
$$$$
Spanish, Wine bars, Cocktail bars
Whalers

Whalers

4.8 4196 votes
$$$$
American, Asian, Latin American
Golden Chicken in bay shore

Golden Chicken in bay shore

4.8 879 votes
$$$$
Peruvian, Spanish
Taquero mucho

Taquero mucho

4.8 321 votes
$$$$
Mexican
Takeshi Sushi Teriyaki

Takeshi Sushi Teriyaki

4.6 148 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Japanese
Sumou Sushi & Hibachi

Sumou Sushi & Hibachi

4.2 1086 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ

JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ

4.8 1061 votes
$$$$
Barbecue, Japanese

Food delivery in Bay Shore

Peter Pan Diner

Peter Pan Diner

4.8 3139 votes
$$$$
American, Seafood, Soups, Burgers, Dessert
Food King Chinese Kitchen

Food King Chinese Kitchen

4.4 224 votes
$$$$
Chinese, Seafood
Amore Pizza

Amore Pizza

3.9 610 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Bo Wah Kitchen

Bo Wah Kitchen

3.8 396 votes
$$$$
Chinese
Golden Star

Golden Star

3.3 249 votes
$$$$
Chinese
Chipotle Mexican Grill

Chipotle Mexican Grill

3 731 votes
$$$$
Mexican, Fast food
North Fork Doughnut Co. Bay Shore

North Fork Doughnut Co. Bay Shore

2.7 417 votes
$$$$
Donuts
Nicky’s on the Bay

Nicky’s on the Bay

4.9 2526 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American
Pollo Campero

Pollo Campero

4.9 2909 votes
$$$$
Latin American, Fast food
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

4.9 6051 votes
$$$$
American, Seafood
Taquero mucho

Taquero mucho

4.8 321 votes
$$$$
Mexican
Roto All Day Cafe

Roto All Day Cafe

4.8 193 votes
$$$$
Pine Aire Fish, Que Rica Comida

Pine Aire Fish, Que Rica Comida

4.8 1177 votes
$$$$
Delis, Seafood
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ

JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ

4.8 1061 votes
$$$$
Barbecue, Japanese
Destination Unknown Beer Company

Destination Unknown Beer Company

4.6 250 votes
$$$$
Kitty Mulligan's Irish Pub

Kitty Mulligan's Irish Pub

4.3 299 votes
$$$$
Irish, American
Tacos Guacamole

Tacos Guacamole

4.2 509 votes
$$$$
Mexican
Bay Shore Bean

Bay Shore Bean

3.8 1004 votes
$$$$
American, Vegetarian, Vegan
Brazas Restaurant & Bar

Brazas Restaurant & Bar

3.2 158 votes
$$$$
Seafood, Cocktail bars
Hacienda Real Restaurant

Hacienda Real Restaurant

3 108 votes
$$$$

Takeaway restaurants in Bay Shore

Galanga

Galanga

4.8 635 votes
$$$$
Thai, Asian
Mediterranean Express - Powered by The Greek

Mediterranean Express - Powered by The Greek

4.8 589 votes
$$$$
Greek, Mediterranean
Buffalo Wild Wings

Buffalo Wild Wings

4.8 1953 votes
$$$$
American
Bango

Bango

4.1 436 votes
$$$$
Gluten-free, Fast food, Healthy food
North Fork Doughnut Co. Bay Shore

North Fork Doughnut Co. Bay Shore

2.7 417 votes
$$$$
Donuts
Pollo Campero

Pollo Campero

4.9 2909 votes
$$$$
Latin American, Fast food
Burger King

Burger King

4.8 1326 votes
$$$$
Fast food, American
Blaze Pizza

Blaze Pizza

4.4 1048 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Fast food, Salads
Dunkin'

Dunkin'

3.3 173 votes
$$$$
Donuts
Bagel Boss East

Bagel Boss East

3.2 788 votes
$$$$
Delis
Buttermilk's Farmhouse

Buttermilk's Farmhouse

4.8 148 votes
$$$$
Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

4.8 1076 votes
$$$$
Italian, Cocktail bars, Wine bars
Pine Aire Fish, Que Rica Comida

Pine Aire Fish, Que Rica Comida

4.8 1177 votes
$$$$
Delis, Seafood
KTO Cuisine

KTO Cuisine

4.8 294 votes
$$$$
Latin American
Kismet Coffee, Kitchen & Cocktails

Kismet Coffee, Kitchen & Cocktails

4.8 173 votes
$$$$
Cocktail bars
Fatty T’s Burger Shack

Fatty T’s Burger Shack

4.8 65 votes
$$$$
Fast food
Whalers

Whalers

4.8 4196 votes
$$$$
American, Asian, Latin American
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ

JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ

4.8 1061 votes
$$$$
Barbecue, Japanese
Chowder Bar

Chowder Bar

4.8 971 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American
Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant

4.4 230 votes
$$$$
Pizza

Seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Salt & Barrel

Salt & Barrel

4.8 4987 votes
$$$$
Seafood, New American, Cocktail bars
Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

4.8 1076 votes
$$$$
Italian, Cocktail bars, Wine bars
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

4.9 6051 votes
$$$$
American, Seafood
Chi Fish Market

Chi Fish Market

4.4 155 votes
$$$$
American, Seafood
The Lakehouse

The Lakehouse

4.8 6411 votes
$$$$
New American, Seafood, American
Fatfish

Fatfish

4.8 4302 votes
$$$$
Seafood
Chowder Bar

Chowder Bar

4.8 971 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American
Deans Seafood

Deans Seafood

3.9 27 votes
$$$$
Seafood
Nicky’s on the Bay

Nicky’s on the Bay

4.9 2526 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American
Nicky's Clam Bar

Nicky's Clam Bar

3.7 640 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American
Whalers

Whalers

4.8 4196 votes
$$$$
American, Asian, Latin American
Nicky's on the Bay

Nicky's on the Bay

1.3 3478 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American, Contemporary
Pine Aire Fish, Que Rica Comida

Pine Aire Fish, Que Rica Comida

4.8 1177 votes
$$$$
Delis, Seafood
Butera's - Bay Shore

Butera's - Bay Shore

4.8 1873 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza
Eat At Ditch

Eat At Ditch

1.7 71 votes
$$$$
Seafood
KPOT Korean BBQ & Hot Pot

KPOT Korean BBQ & Hot Pot

5 1092 votes
$$$$
Korean, Barbecue
Ditch - Bay Shore

Ditch - Bay Shore

3.8 492 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American
Que Rica Comida

Que Rica Comida

1 502 votes
$$$$
Delis
Swept Away

Swept Away

1.7 45 votes
$$$$
American, Seafood, Cocktail bars
Aji 53 Japanese Restaurant

Aji 53 Japanese Restaurant

4 2490 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Japanese, Asian

Pubs & bars in Bay Shore

Great South Bay Brewery

Great South Bay Brewery

4.8 935 votes
$$$$
Cocktail bars
Destination Unknown Beer Company

Destination Unknown Beer Company

4.6 250 votes
$$$$
Rites Brewing

Rites Brewing

4.8 56 votes
$$$$
The Brewers Collective

The Brewers Collective

1.6 52 votes
$$$$
Take Two Brewery

Take Two Brewery

4 17 votes
Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

4.8 1076 votes
$$$$
Italian, Cocktail bars, Wine bars
Beverage barn

Beverage barn

4.2 59 votes
$$$$
Coopersmiths Pub inc.

Coopersmiths Pub inc.

0.4 29 votes
$$$$
Grill
Ghost Brewing Company

Ghost Brewing Company

1.2 26 votes
The Penny Pub

The Penny Pub

3.9 715 votes
$$$$
Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

Verde Kitchen & Cocktails

4.8 4090 votes
$$$$
Mexican, Cocktail bars
The Cortland

The Cortland

4.8 245 votes
$$$$
Goody Two Shoes

Goody Two Shoes

3.8 883 votes
$$$$
Cocktail bars, Salads, Sandwiches
Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille

Changing Times American Sports Bar & Grille

2.5 1935 votes
$$$$
American, Fast food
Wines On Main

Wines On Main

4.3 56 votes
$$$$
Wine bars, Cocktail bars
Fire Island Vines

Fire Island Vines

1.2 85 votes
$$$$
Wine bars, Greek, Mediterranean
Coastal Kitchen

Coastal Kitchen

3 339 votes
$$$$
Cocktail bars, Caribbean, Spanish
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar

Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar

4.8 2229 votes
$$$$
Cocktail bars, Caribbean, Spanish
Kitty Mulligan's Irish Pub

Kitty Mulligan's Irish Pub

4.3 299 votes
$$$$
Irish, American
Napper Tandy’s

Napper Tandy’s

4.8 1613 votes
$$$$
Irish, New American, Seafood, Wine bars, Cocktail bars

Tasty dishes in Bay Shore

Cheese Soup
Cheese Soup
 Bananas Foster
Bananas Foster
 New York–Style Pizza
New York–Style Pizza
 Angel Food Cake
Angel Food Cake
 Succotash
Succotash
 Devil's Food Cake
Devil's Food Cake
 Chocolate-Covered Bacon
Chocolate-Covered Bacon
 Hoppin' John
Hoppin' John
 Hamburgers
Hamburgers

Restaurant features in Bay Shore

Cities near Bay Shore

New York City
New York City

77k restaurants

Brightwaters
Brightwaters

42 restaurants

West New York
West New York

10k restaurants

Islip
Islip

157 restaurants

Brentwood
Brentwood

392 restaurants

Deer Park
Deer Park

429 restaurants

Filters

Location

Location

  • Current location

Types

Rating

Opening hours

Search radius

Any distance
Any distance
0.2 mi
0.5 mi
1 mi
2 mi
5 mi
10 mi
20 mi
50 mi
75 mi
Price

Dishes

Features

Cuisines

Top 10 restaurants in Bay Shore

222 restaurants 222 restaurants
Rating
Rating
Distance
Distance/rating
Popularity
Michelin
Trip
Frommer's
Zomato
Google
Foursquare
Opentable
Yandex
Current location
Point on map
Bay Shore city center
.
Rating
Rating
Distance
Distance/rating
Popularity
Michelin
Trip
Frommer's
Zomato
Google
Foursquare
Opentable
Yandex
Note: 224 non-restaurant eating places are hidden. Show all

Other results

Roadtrip

1. Roadtrip

 Restaurant
5 1261 votes
$$$$
Closed until 12PM
American, Cocktail bars, Salads, Vegetarian options
normal wait staff was friendly and helpful 
KPOT Korean BBQ & Hot Pot

2. KPOT Korean BBQ & Hot Pot

 BBQ, Seafood, Restaurant, Cafeteria, Pub & bar
5 1092 votes
$$$$
Closed until 12PM
Korean, Barbecue, Vegetarian options
bad Not much selection as compared to other korean bbq restaurants we go to 
Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

3. Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering

 Restaurant, Seafood
4.9 6051 votes
$$$$
Closed until 12PM
American, Seafood, Vegetarian options
excellent We came here for restaurant week 
Pecado Mexican

4. Pecado Mexican

 Mexican, Restaurant, Pub & bar
4.9 1886 votes
$$$$
Closed until 4PM
Mexican, Cocktail bars, Vegetarian options
excellent Just had an amazing experience at this Mexican restaurant 
The Lakehouse

5. The Lakehouse

 Restaurant, Seafood
4.8 6411 votes
$$$$
Closed until 12PM
New American, Seafood, American, Vegetarian options
excellent ... tournament and googled best restaurant in long island and The Lakehouse 
Nicky’s on the Bay

6. Nicky’s on the Bay

 Restaurant, Pub & bar, Seafood
4.9 2526 votes
$$$$
Closed until 11AM
Seafood, American, Vegetarian options
excellent ... 10/10/2022 Entire menu half price! 
Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

7. Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

 Sushi, Restaurant
4.8 1453 votes
$$$$
Closed until 1:30PM
excellent All you can eat. Everything was so good nice presentation 
Salt & Barrel

8. Salt & Barrel

 Seafood, Restaurant, Pub & bar
4.8 4987 votes
$$$$
Closed until 3PM
Seafood, New American, Cocktail bars, Vegetarian options
bad I’m not the type to leave bad reviews if you look at my profile 
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

9. Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

 Restaurant, Italian, Seafood, Pub & bar
4.9 2680 votes
$$$$
Closed until 11AM
Italian, Soups, Seafood, Gluten-free, Wine bars, Salads, Vegetarian options
Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

10. Bar Lucy - Italian Restaurant Bay Shore

 Restaurant, Pub & bar, Italian, Seafood, Wine bar, Pizzeria, Steakhouse
4.8 1076 votes
$$$$
Closed until 3PM
Italian, Cocktail bars, Wine bars, Vegetarian options
excellent Where do I even begin? My Wife and I went for date night 
Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

11. Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge

 Sushi, Restaurant, Seafood
4.8 1217 votes
$$$$
Closed until 12PM
Japanese, Sushi, Cocktail bars, Vegetarian options
excellent Wow! What an experience! I loved my food so so much 
Galanga

12. Galanga

 Restaurant
4.8 635 votes
$$$$
Closed until 11AM
Thai, Asian, Vegetarian options
Butera's - Bay Shore

13. Butera's - Bay Shore

 Restaurant, Seafood, Pizzeria, Italian, Pub & bar
4.8 1873 votes
$$$$
Closed until 4:30PM
bad While we experienced wonderful service (no complaints there) the food was 
Magnolias

14. Magnolias

 Restaurant, Seafood, Pub & bar
4.8 106 votes
$$$$
Closed until tomorrow
Spanish, Wine bars, Cocktail bars
excellent WOW! Awesome restaurant and bar 
Whalers

15. Whalers

 Restaurant, Pub & bar, Seafood
4.8 4196 votes
$$$$
Closed until Thursday
American, Asian, Latin American, Vegetarian options
Golden Chicken in bay shore

16. Golden Chicken in bay shore

 Restaurant
4.8 879 votes
$$$$
Closed until 11:30AM
Peruvian, Spanish
excellent Took my brother and my parents here before my flight at LaGuardia 
Taquero mucho

17. Taquero mucho

 Mexican restaurant, Mexican
4.8 321 votes
$$$$
Closed until 12PM
excellent Food is always good but today was one of those days 
Takeshi Sushi Teriyaki

18. Takeshi Sushi Teriyaki

 Restaurant, Sushi
4.5 148 votes
$$$$
Closed until tomorrow
excellent Only sharing my review of the food because it s a primarily a take-out 
Sumou Sushi & Hibachi

19. Sumou Sushi & Hibachi

 Restaurant, Sushi
4.2 1086 votes
$$$$
Closed until tomorrow
excellent ... feel I was at family’s restaurant, prices are good and food delicious 
JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ

20. JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ

 BBQ, Restaurant
4.8 1061 votes
$$$$
Closed until 12PM
Barbecue, Japanese, Vegetarian options
excellent We’ve been regular customers for two years now, and we’re always happy 
avatar Advisor Pierre