Add a photo
20 photos
You can visit this pizzeria after seeing Garrett Public Library. Perfectly cooked pizza, chicken bacon ranch and bacon can make a favorable impression on you. The positive aspect of Boxcar Pizza is that the staff is terrific. Cool service is something clients agree upon here. The nice atmosphere offers a relaxing feel to a clients' stay at this place. The average rating of this spot on Google is 4.5.
Frequently mentioned in reviews
See allLess
Visitors' reviews on Boxcar Pizza
/ 38
Add your review
S
Request content removal
Sammy M
3 months ago on Google
Absolutely amazing! All the time every time. Never had a messed up order! 10/ 10 recommend.. Must try the gut buster and the pizza rolls are ! Thank you for consistently providing delicious food Price per person: $10–20 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Crazy Dough, Nachos, Sausage Roll, 12 Supreme Goodness, Chef Salad lg, 12 Trainwreck BBQ
R
Request content removal
Rachel Wallace
5 months ago on Google
Stopped in for their pizza ended up getting a bit of everything. It was our first time and we will be back. Service was great, She said it would be 30-35 minutes. Was actually done sooner. The price was actually not as bad as I thought it would be. Great value for the price. Loved everything Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
C
Request content removal
Curtis Carr
7 months ago on Google
First time I’ve visited Boxcar Pizza. Unfortunately, it will be my last. Very underwhelming, run of the mill, pizza. Not impressive. I could jazz up a Tombstone better than that, for half the price. I could go on and on. However, I’ll just say, if you’re looking for a great pizza in Garrett or Auburn area, go to Coterie. P.S. I picked up. I did not really get to experience the atmosphere. However, it’s not going to make up for the pizza. That’s the reason for the low score on that. Ordered 2 personal pizzas and the crazy dough. Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 1 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 2
B
Response from the owner
7 months ago
Thank you for the review. We would highly suggest you try one of our speciality pizzas before never visiting again. We specialize in all fresh ingredients and strive for great taste. When you order personal pizzas you aren’t getting the full effect of our restaurant.
Show replies (1)
All reviews
Address
105 N Randolph St, Garrett, Indiana, USA
Features
Сredit cards accepted
Takeaway
Wheelchair accessible
Delivery
Wi-Fi
Parking
TV
Opening hours
| SundaySun | 4PM-8PM |
| MondayMon | 4PM-8PM |
| TuesdayTue | 4PM-8PM |
| WednesdayWed | 4PM-8PM |
| ThursdayThu | 4PM-8PM |
| FridayFri | 4PM-10PM |
| SaturdaySat | 4PM-10PM |
Report incorrect information
