Casey's

Name: Casey's
Address: 4300 N Calumet Ave, Valparaiso, Indiana, USA
Telephone: +12194769493
Price range: $
Rating: 1.4

96 votes

#71 of 71 pizza restaurants in Valparaiso

1 more branch in Valparaiso

Open now 4AM - 10PM

Updated 2 months ago

All photos Food Exterior Interior Dessert Drink

Add a photo

53 photos

Casey's is distinguished by interior and food

This is the photo showing drink and food at Casey's

Many visitors say that waiters offer perfectly cooked pizza here. At this pizzeria, clients may drink good coffee. The competent staff welcomes guests all year round. Enjoyable service is what a number of people point out characterizing Casey's. But google users assigned the score of 4.1 to this place.

Frequently mentioned in reviews

great service

pizza meat cheese salads doughnuts coffee

Ratings of Casey's

Google

(4.1/5)

Trip

(1/5)

Visitors' reviews on Casey's

/ 57

Search visitors’ reviews

Add your review

Request content removal

Ashley Nilson a month ago on Google

Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Response from the owner 29 days ago

We appreciate the rating and hope to see you again soon!

Show replies (1)

Request content removal

David Rigdon a month ago on Google

They had fresh breakfast pizza. Food: 5 Service: 4 Atmosphere: 4

Response from the owner 29 days ago

Hi! We're delighted you enjoy Casey's for our wide range of offerings—from gas and pizza to drinks and snacks. Whether it's our refreshing soda, hot coffee, or car essentials, we're here to serve you with a smile. Don't forget to join our rewards program for more perks! Looking forward to seeing you again soon!

Show replies (1)

Request content removal

ewdog25 8 years ago on Google

Love Casey's, however I have been here to the Calumet store a dozen times and they have had cigarettes I smoke in stock only 3 times, and the 3 times we have ordered pizza from there it was under cooked and doughy. I know this is a new store and there are some growing pains but if you want good Casey's pizza you will still need to go to the westville store. I don't know if they aren't measuring dough properly, or the oven converyor is too fast, or oven temp isn't as hot as it should be but we have been disappointed everytime with the pizza. Last time we took it back and they would only remake 1 of them as the other one "looked ok" even though I took it to work and had to throw it away because of how under cooked it was. I have talked to other people and they have had the same complaints of under cooked pizzas from here as well. I don't like the "other gas station" across the street but I am forced to go there because this store isn't in stock of items and the pizza which we love has been sub par

All reviews

+1 219-476-9493

Pizza

$$$$ Price range per person $10-$20