Casey's

Name: Casey's
Address: 1045 University Ave, Henry, Illinois, USA
Telephone: +13093643066
Price range: $
Rating: 3.9

59 votes

#2 of 10 restaurants in Henry

Open now 4AM - 12AM

Updated 1 month ago

Add a photo

12 photos

Don't forget to eat good pizza at this pizzeria. The hospitable staff works hard, stays positive and makes this place wonderful. Professional service is a strong point that plays a great role for the success of Casey's. But google users haven't given this place a high rating.

Frequently mentioned in reviews

takeaway food delivery

pies completo cheese popara seafood pizza breadsticks marinara pizza vegetable pizza

See allLess

Ratings of Casey's

Google

(3.9/5)

Trip

Not rated yet

Facebook

Not rated yet

Visitors' reviews on Casey's

/ 28

Search visitors’ reviews

Add your review

Request content removal

Cynthia Crawley 3 months ago on Google

I went to your location around 630. I just wanted 2 slices of pizza. There was no sausage. The pepperoni was 45 minutes old. Apparently they had a supreme they used to fill in display. I asked the young lady who was in back talking with a coworker...who informed me that they were very busy and would NOT be making any more any time soon. No " I'm sorry...I can make one if you don't mind waiting".....Apparently a large pizza order before had exhausted her and her customer service! When Michelle is present, the service is excellent and the case always has a fresh selection. If I was a rude customer I would have ordered a sausage pizza and told her that I changed my mind after it was done ..I just wanted 2 slices. BUT I didn't....I bought one of the slices of supreme and 1 pepperoni which was the most disgusting piece of pizza ever purchased at your location! Some people can't eat supremes or greasy pepperonis....... Please... make sure your staff understands customer service and and the importance of fresh food........based on some of these comments......it's obvious the evening staff need additional training.

Response from the owner 3 months ago

We are disappointed to hear about your experience, as it does not reflect Casey's values or dedication to our community. We will be sharing your feedback with the teams internally. We would also like the opportunity to discuss this further with you. Please contact us at https://www.caseys.com/contact with more specific details.

Show replies (1)

Request content removal

Jess Miller 8 months ago on Google

My kid ordered a pizza late night 02/04/26 at about 7:30 ish. Unfortunately, came with a free band aid. Umm, my kid is gross and ate it. Said it was okay. So points for that I guess? Expensive for what it is, but only thing available at that hour. But this is a gas station in a small town, so I guess I don't expect much. We have much better pizza in town, but you have to catch them when it's open. Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $10–20 Food: 2 Service: 3 Atmosphere: 3 Vegetarian offerings: Vegetarian menu or section

Response from the owner 7 months ago

Hi Jess. Thank you for your feedback. We take food safety and sanitation very seriously and would like to investigate this further. Please reach out to us at https://www.caseys.com/contact with more details so we can take prompt action.

Show replies (1)

Request content removal

Carissa Pyles 2 years ago on Google

Food: 3 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 3 Order type: Takeaway Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Recommended dishes: Casey's Salted Caramel Cookies 3oz Kid-friendliness: Yes always

All reviews

+1 309-364-3066

Pizza

$$$$ Price range per person $20-$30