Casey's

Name: Casey's
Address: 3860 Bell Rd, Newburgh, Indiana, USA
Telephone: +18124165410
Price range: $
Rating: 2.3

13 votes

#19 of 20 pizza restaurants in Newburgh

Add a photo

4 photos

Add a photo

Add your opinion

Guests don't like pizza at this pizzeria. From the guests' point of view, employees are rough here. Despite the popularity among visitors, the weak side of Casey's is its fast service. This place is not highly appreciated by Google users who provided it a below average rating.

Frequently mentioned in reviews

takeaway food delivery lunch

sausage pizza pepperoni pizza sausages sandwiches pepperoni pizza puto

See allLess

Ratings of Casey's

Google

(2.4/5)

Trip

Not rated yet

Facebook

(1/5)

Visitors' opinions on Casey's

/ 12

Search visitors’ opinions

Add your opinion

Request content removal

paigee waller 4 months ago on Google

Went in last night to get gas and the guy that works in the back kitchen area “young white male with brown hair” was at the front counter talkimg with the pregnant girl. Not only was he visibly inebriated, he smelled so loudly like marijuana that it made me sick to my stomach. It could have possibly been the young lady, but being that she was pregnant I highly doubt it. Please Casyes inform your workers that there is a time and a place for this type of behavior. I will be taking my business to the Marathon across the street until y’all can get it together. Service: Take out Price per person: $20–30 Food: 4 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1

Request content removal

Michael Lang 5 months ago on Google

Ordered & paid for pizza online. They didn't have my order at all. Guy at counter was lackadaisical about it. Okay, so maybe he's not the best at customer service & your biz had tech issues. However, I went on your website & sent an inquiry on 4/5. No response! Food: 5 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 5

Request content removal

Greg Duff a year ago on Google

Ok, so one of the only gas stations in Newburgh that sell flex fuel for my truck. Can not even go at night to get gas because for some reason it 2023 and they close. Not even open when they are suppose to be. It 5:00am on a Friday and closed. I know of 10 people that have tried to go there on the way to work. You would get alot of business if you open 24 hr even if it's just for gas. I called at 5am he said they were open. Went to get gas I was on E. I get there not open thus is at 515 am. Had to go somewhere else to get my gas. Well ran out and stuck on side of road. Thanks Casey's appreciate employees can not make it to work on time. OPEN THE PUMPS AT NIGHT OR JUST STAY OPEN.

Response from the owner a year ago

Thanks for alerting us, Greg. Any changes to our operating hours should immediately be updated on all available platforms. We'd appreciate the chance to chat with you directly. You can reach out to us here: https://www.caseys.com/contact.

Show replies (1)