Casey's

Name: Casey's
Address: 1306 4 Mile Rd, Wind Point, Wisconsin, USA
Telephone: +12626392225
Price range: $
Rating: 2.5

121 votes

#11 of 12 pizza restaurants in Caledonia

#1 of 1 pizza restaurant in Wind Point

Open now 5AM - 10PM

Updated 2 months ago

All photos Food Exterior Drink

Add a photo

38 photos

The image of food and exterior at Casey's

Check out the photo depicting food and beverage at Casey's

Pizza is the world's favourite fast food

The chef at this pizzeria cooks good pizza. The gracious staff welcomes people all year round. Enjoyable service is something that visitors highlight in their reviews. Prices at Casey's deserve attention as they're affordable. But google users haven't given this place a high rating.

Frequently mentioned in reviews

takeaway Meal

breakfast great service

pizza pepperoni pizza pepperoni meat bacon pork cheese

Ratings of Casey's

Foursquare

(6.5/10)

Google

(3.9/5)

115

Trip

Not rated yet

Facebook

(1/5)

Visitors' reviews on Casey's

/ 90

Search visitors’ reviews

Add your review

Request content removal

JJ B a month ago on Google

Its a pretty good gas station. It definitely doesn't beat a Kwik Trip, but it'll do. The employees are nice and do a good job. Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 4 Recommended dishes: Sausage Breakfast Pizza

Response from the owner a month ago

Thank you for the great rating! We can’t wait to have you back!

Show replies (1)

Request content removal

Heidi Shufelt a month ago on Google

Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Response from the owner a month ago

Thank you so much for taking the time to leave us a rating.

Show replies (1)

Request content removal

Kate Elisa 3 months ago on Google

I've stopped at this Casey's pretty regularly for lunch because it's close to work, but after today's experience I'll be taking my business elsewhere. My issue wasn't the food safety policy, it was how it was handled. My friend wanted the pizza slice behind another one, so I carefully moved the front slice just enough to grab the one behind it. An employee immediately came over and said she had to throw the slice away because I had touched it. I completely understand if that's the policy, and I have no problem with that. What bothered me was what happened next. When I explained that I had tried to be careful, she responded, "No. I know you touched it. I watched the whole time." At that point the slice was already being thrown away, so there really wasn't any benefit to arguing with me about what I did or didn't touch. A simple, "I'm sorry, but because of our food safety policy I have to discard it," would've been perfectly fine. Instead, I felt like I was being corrected and talked down to over an honest mistake. If customers aren't supposed to move or touch pizza slices, I'd recommend providing tongs or disposable gloves instead of only the bags used after the pizza is selected. It would help avoid situations like this entirely. I've worked in customer service for years, so I completely understand that policies have to be enforced. I just also believe they can be enforced with kindness. Unfortunately, this experience left a bad enough impression that I'll be going somewhere else for lunch. Food: 4 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 1 Meal type: Lunch Price per person: $10–20

Response from the owner 3 months ago

Thank you for sharing your feedback, Kate. It sounds like we're not firing on all cylinders. We want to ensure we are always providing a 5-star experience for every guest. We are sharing your feedback with our teams internally and will continue making improvements. We hope you visit us again soon.

Show replies (1)

All reviews

+1 262-639-2225

Pizza

$$$$ Price range per person $1-$10