ClosedOpens at 11AM
Updated 3 months ago
Add a photo
79 photos
Order dishes of Italian cuisine at this pizzeria. You will like its food, particularly good Pepperoni, cheese salads and gluten-free pizza. Taste tasty apple pie at Cottage Inn Pizza Hilliard.
At this place, you can order food as a takeaway. The appealing staff welcomes visitors all year round. Terrific service is something that guests note in their comments. Prices at this spot claim to be adequate. As most reviewers affirm, the atmosphere is exotic. Google users awarded this pizzeria 4.1.
Frequently mentioned in reviews
See allLess
Visitors' reviews on Cottage Inn Pizza Hilliard
/ 166
Add your review
Request content removal
Mary Toy
6 months ago on Google
Best pizza and sub that I have had in a very long time. So much so that we have had it 3 times in the last week and a half. So delicious. Thank you! Great job! Keep up the great work! Food: 5 Service: 5
Request content removal
Jackie Marie
6 months ago on Google
Very good first-time experience, greeted immediately, served food fast, received excellent service - highly recommend. Got the Brookie and deep dish pepperoni. Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Request content removal
Daniel Jahns
10 years ago on Google
Cottage Inn Pizza Hilliard, Ohio – Cemetary RoadFound paper baked in between the crust and the cheese of the pizza! We were sure it was paper because it had writing on it.Called the store to speak to the manager. Now, being pizza enthusiasts, we understand that mistakes will be made (especially when the entire staff seems to be composed of kids who were not in any sort of uniform and barely looked legal working age). However, the kid who answered the phone acted semi-professionally and seemed concerned. We could hear him voicing this concern to the manager in the background.The manager picked up the phone and proceeded to try to convince us that whatever issue we were having was a result of the new method corporate uses in the production of the pizzas. So, Cottage Inn Pizzas are now assembled in their entirety at an offsite corporate factory and then shipped off to the stores to be reheated, absolving the franchise owners from any accountability??? We order ordered pizza from this Cottage Inn all the time and have never had an issue like this before. We simply wanted an explanation and a new, paperless pizza. The manager started screaming and yelling saying it was “not [their] problem” and that “we can do whatever we want.” He then hung up.Needless to say, we certainly did not expect to be met with hostility and screamed at. This one event may have ruined Cottage Inn for us, forever.
All reviews
$$$$
Price range per person
$10-$20
© OpenStreetMaps
contributors
Address
4674 Cemetery Rd, Hilliard, Ohio, USA
Features
Delivery
Takeaway
Сredit cards accepted
Wheelchair accessible
Parking
Opening hours
| SundaySun | Closed |
| MondayMon | 11AM-9PM |
| TuesdayTue | 11AM-9PM |
| WednesdayWed | 11AM-9PM |
| ThursdayThu | 11AM-9PM |
| FridayFri | 11AM-10PM |
| SaturdaySat | 11AM-10PM |
Website
Instagram
@Cottageinn
Report incorrect information
