Open now
12PM - 10:30PM
Updated 2 months ago
Add a photo
166 photos
Cooks at this confectionary restaurant do their best to provide visitors with tasty ice cream. Google gives it 4.6 so you can select Ice Cream Charlie's to spend a good time here.
Frequently mentioned in reviews
Visitors' reviews on Ice Cream Charlie's
/ 289
Add your review
Request content removal
Pat Foote
a month ago on Google
Great little private ice cream shop. Love it!
Request content removal
Shonna Dubose
a month ago on Google
The ice cream was overpriced and was not sweet and wasn’t worth the money and then on top of all of that they don’t take credit card. You have to have cash.
Request content removal
Brianna
2 years ago on Google
So, I went into Ice Cream Charlie’s years ago and for whatever reason I never went back, (keep reading I promise this is a positive review), & Mike's Ice Cream in Secaucus closing was basically the end of an era for my ice cream addiction. When I was pregnant I was there at LEAST four times a week, no wonder I gained so much weight . AND that craving never went away after I gave birth. It could be 10am or 3am or any time in between and I’d be craving an Oreo ice cream from Mikes. I always stocked up on their pints to make sure I had it easily available. Sadly when they closed my craving was still here, I ran out of pints, and I had to find a place to fill that void in my stomach & heart. I went through an ice cream identity crisis—Carvel, Dairy Queen, Cake & Cone, Ben & Jerry's... it was like a bad blind date after another. Nothing quite hit the spot like Mike's Oreo goodness. But then, like a dairy-filled miracle, I rediscovered Ice Cream Charlie's, (still unsure as to why I never went back in the first place) and it was like reuniting with an old friend who never judged my late-night cravings. And to find out they're in cahoots with Mike's? The owner of this place and Mike were really close friends. It's like ice cream conspiracy theory, but tastier! Now I’m back in the game, stocked up on a pint and ready to conquer those cravings like a true dessert warrior. The chocolate peanut butter also got a huge thumbs up from my friend. I can’t wait to add this place to my weekly routine. Who knew ice cream could have such a plot twist? Only downside is it’s Cash only, but that just means have your cash ready. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Order type: Take out Meal type: Other Price per person: $10–20 Recommended dishes: Oreos
All reviews
$$$$
Price range per person
$1-$10
© OpenStreetMaps
contributors
Address
200 Park Ave, Rutherford, New Jersey, USA
Features
Takeaway
Cash only
No outdoor seating
No delivery
Wheelchair accessible
Parking
Opening hours
| SundaySun | 12PM-10:30PM |
| MondayMon | 12PM-10:30PM |
| TuesdayTue | 12PM-10:30PM |
| WednesdayWed | 12PM-10:30PM |
| ThursdayThu | 12PM-10:30PM |
| FridayFri | 12PM-10:30PM |
| SaturdaySat | 12PM-10:30PM |
Website
Instagram
@icecreamcharlies
Report incorrect information
