Randy's Neighbor's Inn

In the heart of West Allis lies Randy's Neighborhood Inn, a cozy establishment that serves up some of the best fish fry in town. The ambiance is dive bar chic with a local atmosphere and classic 50's and 60's music playing in the background. The interior design is no frills with about a dozen tables on one side and a bar with a few high tops on the other. The prices are reasonable, with the all-you-can-eat fish fry on Fridays being a steal at $13.95 per person.

Located on a street with ample parking, Randy's also offers outdoor seating for those who prefer to dine al fresco. The menu features homemade German potato salad, creamy coleslaw, fries, and marble rye bread, all served family-style alongside the beer-battered cod. In addition to the fish fry, Randy's also serves up delicious cocktails like the old fashioned sour with olives, soft drinks, and wines.

The service is friendly and attentive, with staff members treating guests like old friends. Regulars rave about the fish fry, which is always hot and fresh out of the kitchen. While reservations are recommended, walk-ins are welcome, but be prepared to wait as the place can get quite busy. Overall, Randy's Neighborhood Inn is a must-visit eatery for anyone looking for a classic Wisconsin fish fry experience.