New York Pizza Pub

Add to wishlist
Add to compare
Closed
Pub & bar, Pizzeria in Kill Devil Hills
Add a photo
14 photos
Try out pizza at New York Pizza Pub
Take a seat at one of the tables at New York Pizza Pub
Pizza is the world's most beloved fast food
Meals at New York Pizza Pub
Food at New York Pizza Pub
Check out how New York Pizza Pub looks inside
Meals at New York Pizza Pub
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Takeaway from New York Pizza Pub
New York Pizza Pub is a full Italian Grille Restaurant with a full service bar. We offer Dine in, Carry Out and Delivery! We are opened 7 days a week! Monday thriugh Friday 4pm to 9pm; Saturday and Sunday 12pm to 9pm! Every Sunday is Sunday Funday Football! We have food and drinks specials all day on Sundays! Head on over to www.nypizzapub.com for delivery option and menu! 2217 S Croatan Highway Nags Head, 252-441-2660

This bar is recommended for the Italian cuisine served. Here you will be able to taste perfectly cooked grilled calamari, ribeye and classic caesar salads. Most guests recommend trying tasty grilled pineapple, sweet fried dough and brioche toasts. Many visitors mention that you can drink delicious draft beer, Sangria or marsala at New York Pizza Pub. Visit this place and have good smoothies.

Musicians perform live music in the evening. Most users indicate that the staff is courteous. The fabulous service shows a high level of quality at this place. Prices are found attractive here. You will appreciate the spectacular decor and calm atmosphere of this spot. As for the Google rating, this bar achieved 4.2.

Frequently mentioned in reviews

See allLess

Visitors' opinions on New York Pizza Pub

/ 509
wp austin Request content removal
Another OBX pizza fave! Highly recommend!
David Darr Request content removal
Great pizza and salad. Fast for a hungry family and open during the winter.
Phil S. Request content removal
Overall ** I think the only people that might call this New York Pizza are people who have never had New York Pizza. The pizza itself I would not ever desire again and I certainly hope there are better options here at OBX to find. New York Pizza Pub gets 2.42 Stars on the weighted grading scale. Setting *** The restaurant itself is actually pretty cool space but probably not ideal for a restaurant and better suited as a music venue and that looks like what it was originally designed for. The dining room has two levels, the lower is wide open space with a good size stage in the front and a large wall facing bar that did not have stools to sit on and I suspect it is only used during music events. The second level is a mezzanine that wraps all the way around. I would say the place overall looked generally clean but a bit run down. The turn in to the parking lot is very tight and the lot itself is crumbling, poorly lined and was partially flooded due to moderate rain. Service ** We called in a pick up order which was pretty straight forward and the counter girls were friendly enough but the kitchen could not get their timing together. The wings and salad were ready about 15 minutes before the pizza so as you might suspect by the time we got to the wings they were cold. As a side note their Covid-19 guidelines are confusing as they have a separate door for pick up orders with a sign that suggests you to use it but then when you get to it it says exit only. Seemingly everyone getting to go ignored the exit only sign. The use of masks was also randomly followed. Food ** We ordered two "crispy" pies, two Greek salads, wings and garlic knots. As far as the pizza goes, opening the box revealed what resembled Domino's pizza. Only one of the two pizzas was "crispy" but it didn't help save it from the incredibly thick, chewy crust, sweet tasting red sauce and what I suppose passes as cheese. If you like Domino's then I suspect you will like this. The wings may have been good hot but were average cold. They are breaded and huge, neither attribute I appreciate. The Greek salads were embarrassing in my opinion. There was almost nothing Greek about them except for a small bit of Feta cheese. I do give them credit for wrapping the grilled chicken separately in foil in order to stop the warm chicken from wilting the salad. Value *** I don't consider it terribly unreasonable as the whole bill totaled $107 to feed 8 people but I use the term feed loosely.
$$$$ Price range per person $11 - $30
New York Pizza Pub on map
© OpenStreetMap contributions
Get directions
2217 S Croatan Hwy
Nags Head, North Carolina, USA
Address
2217 S Croatan Hwy, Nags Head, North Carolina, USA
Features
Takeaway
Opening hours
SundaySun 11:30AM-9PM
MondayMon 11:30AM-9PM
TuesdayTue 11:30AM-9PM
WednesdayWed 11:30AM-9PM
ThursdayThu 11:30AM-9PM
FridayFri 11:30AM-9PM
SaturdaySat 11:30AM-9PM
Website
Instagram
@mahimahisobx

Tasty dishes in Nags Head

Restaurant features in Nags Head

Updated on: