Add a photo
16 photos
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Many visitors come to enjoy nicely cooked sandwiches and good salads. A lot of guests highlight that the staff is energetic at this place. People mention that the service is fabulous here. There is pretty atmosphere at this restaurant. Most clients who visited Piccadilly Square rated it 4.8 on Facebook.
Frequently mentioned in reviews
See allLess
Visitors' opinions on Piccadilly Square Eatery
/ 33
Add your opinion
Request content removal
Thomas C.
4 years ago on Yelp
Piccadilly Square is a small eatery right in the village of Cato offering sandwiches, soups and more. Not much to eat right in the village so it was nice to find a little sandwich shop like Piccadilly right around the corner. Tried it with one of my friends the first time. They have many different options with different, interesting combinations. The first time I went, I got a spicy turkey sandwich which I can't remember the exact name of, while my buddy chose The Finnegan. We were surprised at how big the sandwiches were. Huge portions, low price. Both were very good, but we both agreed that the ciabatta they put their sandwiches on were a bit too big and bready. We both enjoyed that they got some nice grill marks on the sandwiches though. Tried it again a couple weeks later with some other friends and went for a buffalo chicken sub. It was good, but it was a cold sub, and I was expecting (and would've rather had) it hot. Nothing was bad, just thrown off that it was cold. Buddy of mine tried a meatball sub and said they were very good. Again, large portions. Service is always very friendly. The building is a nice, big wooden barn looking building and it's very clean and nicely decorated inside. Definitely a nice place to grab a quick bite if ever in the area.
Request content removal
Lou Ann Roberts
5 years ago on Facebook
yummy food! I love the rice pudding.
Request content removal
Andi Terpening
5 years ago on Facebook
Crystal is the best sandwich maker, ever!! The rueben is out of this world and probably the best I've ever had. The bread is so fresh and they don't skimp on the meat. There were 8 of us in our party and Crystal came in on a night off to help out with our orders. We love her! Everyone in our group absolutely loved their meals, not one complaint. Keep up the great work Piccadilly - we'll be back!!
All opinions
$$$$
Price range per person up to $10
Address
2488 W Main St, Cato, New York, USA
Features
Outdoor seating
Сredit cards accepted
Parking
No booking
Takeaway
Opening hours
| SundaySun | Closed |
| MondayMon | 11AM-8PM |
| TuesdayTue | 11AM-8PM |
| WednesdayWed | 11AM-8PM |
| ThursdayThu | 11AM-8PM |
| FridayFri | 11AM-8PM |
| SaturdaySat | 11AM-8PM |
