Find best restaurants! For business
Search
Where:

Restaurants in Sayville

Redefine Meals

Redefine Meals

5 879 votes
$$$$
Butera's

Butera's

4.8 3634 votes
$$$$
Italian, American, Pizza, Seafood, Wine bars
The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

4.8 823 votes
$$$$
Cocktail bars, Dessert, Salads
Koi Sushi

Koi Sushi

4.6 365 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Asian, Chinese, Japanese
Off The Block Kitchen & Meats

Off The Block Kitchen & Meats

4.8 1912 votes
$$$$
New American
The Cull House

The Cull House

4.8 2041 votes
$$$$
Seafood, Fast food, Wine bars, Beer bars
Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

4.9 1750 votes
$$$$
New American, American, Fusion, Italian
Local Burger - Sayville - Restaurant and Bar

Local Burger - Sayville - Restaurant and Bar

2.2 83 votes
$$$$
Barbecue, Fast food, New American
T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville)

T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville)

4.5 640 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Chinese, Asian, Japanese
Mallory Square Restaurant and Bar

Mallory Square Restaurant and Bar

3.4 82 votes
$$$$
American
Blackbirds' Grille

Blackbirds' Grille

4.3 1952 votes
$$$$
Cajun, Creole, Fast food, American, Southern
Parlor House Grill

Parlor House Grill

3.5 807 votes
$$$$
American
YOYO CHICKEN ( BOHEMIA )

YOYO CHICKEN ( BOHEMIA )

4.8 106 votes
$$$$
Fast food
Sayville Pizza & Metros on main Italian Restaurant

Sayville Pizza & Metros on main Italian Restaurant

3.5 515 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Dessert, Wine bars
Aegean Cafe

Aegean Cafe

3.2 872 votes
$$$$
Greek, Mediterranean
Metros on Main

Metros on Main

4.5 111 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Spanish, Salads
The Sayville Inn

The Sayville Inn

2.8 867 votes
$$$$
American, Seafood, Fast food
Jade Garden

Jade Garden

3.4 133 votes
$$$$
Chinese
Canz Bar & Grill

Canz Bar & Grill

4 266 votes
$$$$
American, Beer bars
Sayville Athletic Club

Sayville Athletic Club

4.3 133 votes
$$$$
Fast food, Sandwiches

Food delivery in Sayville

Sal's Pizzeria and Catering

Sal's Pizzeria and Catering

2.9 521 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Domino's Pizza

Domino's Pizza

1.2 204 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Sandwiches
Sayville Athletic Club

Sayville Athletic Club

4.3 133 votes
$$$$
Fast food, Sandwiches
Brownstones Coffee Sayville

Brownstones Coffee Sayville

4.8 324 votes
$$$$
Sandwiches
Sayville Falls Mini Golf

Sayville Falls Mini Golf

4.8 339 votes
$$$$
The Greenery

The Greenery

4.8 199 votes
$$$$
Salads
Friendly's

Friendly's

4.8 795 votes
$$$$
American, Fast food
Koi Sushi

Koi Sushi

4.6 365 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Asian, Chinese, Japanese
Metros on Main

Metros on Main

4.5 111 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Spanish, Salads
T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville)

T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville)

4.5 640 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Chinese, Asian, Japanese
Carvel

Carvel

3.5 71 votes
$$$$
Jade Garden

Jade Garden

3.4 133 votes
$$$$
Chinese
Umberto's of Sayville

Umberto's of Sayville

3.3 577 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Vegan, Vegetarian
Beijing Kitchen

Beijing Kitchen

2.6 171 votes
$$$$
Chinese, Seafood
Off The Block Kitchen & Meats

Off The Block Kitchen & Meats

4.8 1912 votes
$$$$
New American
Sayville Bean Coffee House

Sayville Bean Coffee House

4.4 190 votes
$$$$
Texas Taco

Texas Taco

4.3 605 votes
$$$$
Mexican
Canz Bar & Grill

Canz Bar & Grill

4 266 votes
$$$$
American, Beer bars
Ramen Ramen

Ramen Ramen

4 149 votes
$$$$
Ramen, Hawaiian, Japanese, Korean
Five Points Cafe

Five Points Cafe

3.9 1771 votes
$$$$
American, Cocktail bars, Salads

Takeaway restaurants in Sayville

Off The Block Kitchen & Meats

Off The Block Kitchen & Meats

4.8 1912 votes
$$$$
New American
Umberto's of Sayville

Umberto's of Sayville

3.3 577 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Vegan, Vegetarian
YOYO CHICKEN ( BOHEMIA )

YOYO CHICKEN ( BOHEMIA )

4.8 106 votes
$$$$
Fast food
The Cull House

The Cull House

4.8 2041 votes
$$$$
Seafood, Fast food, Wine bars, Beer bars
Dunkin'

Dunkin'

3.7 246 votes
$$$$
Donuts
Sayville Chocolatier

Sayville Chocolatier

3.2 155 votes
$$$$
Dessert
Dunkin'

Dunkin'

2.9 303 votes
$$$$
Donuts
Fritzsche's Bakery

Fritzsche's Bakery

2.7 224 votes
$$$$
The Greenery

The Greenery

4.8 199 votes
$$$$
Salads
Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen

Dark Horse Coffee & Kitchen

4.8 371 votes
$$$$
Sayville Sandwich

Sayville Sandwich

4.7 177 votes
$$$$
Delis, Salads, Sandwiches
Starbucks Coffee Company

Starbucks Coffee Company

4.3 107 votes
$$$$
Ramen Ramen

Ramen Ramen

4 149 votes
$$$$
Ramen, Hawaiian, Japanese, Korean
Cornucopia Health Foods

Cornucopia Health Foods

3.8 582 votes
$$$$
Delis
Starbucks Coffee Company

Starbucks Coffee Company

2.7 390 votes
$$$$
Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

4.9 1750 votes
$$$$
New American, American, Fusion, Italian
Brownstones Coffee Sayville

Brownstones Coffee Sayville

4.8 324 votes
$$$$
Sandwiches
The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

4.8 823 votes
$$$$
Cocktail bars, Dessert, Salads
Butera's

Butera's

4.8 3634 votes
$$$$
Italian, American, Pizza, Seafood, Wine bars
Portly Villager

Portly Villager

4.5 570 votes
$$$$
American

Seafood restaurants in Sayville

The Cull House

The Cull House

4.8 2041 votes
$$$$
Seafood, Fast food, Wine bars, Beer bars
Butera's

Butera's

4.8 3634 votes
$$$$
Italian, American, Pizza, Seafood, Wine bars
Blackbirds' Grille

Blackbirds' Grille

4.3 1952 votes
$$$$
Cajun, Creole, Fast food, American, Southern
Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

4.9 1750 votes
$$$$
New American, American, Fusion, Italian
The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

4.8 823 votes
$$$$
Cocktail bars, Dessert, Salads
The Sayville Inn

The Sayville Inn

2.8 867 votes
$$$$
American, Seafood, Fast food
Koi Sushi

Koi Sushi

4.6 365 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Asian, Chinese, Japanese
Parlor House Grill

Parlor House Grill

3.5 807 votes
$$$$
American
Blue Island Seafood Market

Blue Island Seafood Market

$$$$
Seafood
T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville)

T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville)

4.5 640 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Chinese, Asian, Japanese
Baymans Katch Clam and Seafood

Baymans Katch Clam and Seafood

The Seaside Seafood Co.

The Seaside Seafood Co.

Mallory Square Restaurant and Bar

Mallory Square Restaurant and Bar

3.4 82 votes
$$$$
American
Texas Taco

Texas Taco

4.3 605 votes
$$$$
Mexican
Beijing Kitchen

Beijing Kitchen

2.6 171 votes
$$$$
Chinese, Seafood
Sayville Falls Mini Golf

Sayville Falls Mini Golf

4.8 339 votes
$$$$
Five Points Cafe

Five Points Cafe

3.9 1771 votes
$$$$
American, Cocktail bars, Salads
Ramen Ramen

Ramen Ramen

4 149 votes
$$$$
Ramen, Hawaiian, Japanese, Korean
Island Fishing Supplies

Island Fishing Supplies

$$$$
Seafood
Aegean Cafe

Aegean Cafe

3.2 872 votes
$$$$
Greek, Mediterranean

Pizza restaurants in Sayville

Sal's Pizzeria and Catering

Sal's Pizzeria and Catering

2.9 521 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Umberto's of Sayville

Umberto's of Sayville

3.3 577 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Vegan, Vegetarian
Sayville Pizza & Metros on main Italian Restaurant

Sayville Pizza & Metros on main Italian Restaurant

3.5 515 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Dessert, Wine bars
Metros on Main

Metros on Main

4.5 111 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Spanish, Salads
Domino's Pizza

Domino's Pizza

1.2 204 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Sandwiches
Butera's

Butera's

4.8 3634 votes
$$$$
Italian, American, Pizza, Seafood, Wine bars
Station Pub

Station Pub

4.6 219 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Salads
7-Eleven

7-Eleven

3.3 74 votes
$$$$
Pizza
7-Eleven

7-Eleven

2.9 65 votes
$$$$
Pizza
Downtown Pizza & Sub

Downtown Pizza & Sub

$$$$
Pizza
Pine Bistro & Pizza

Pine Bistro & Pizza

$$$$
French, Italian, Pizza
Downtown Pizza

Downtown Pizza

Pizza
RJ's Pizza

RJ's Pizza

6 votes
$$$$
Pizza
Mark Anthony Pizza

Mark Anthony Pizza

13 votes
$$$$
Pizza

Advisor Pierre selections in Sayville

Tasty dishes in Sayville

Cheese Soup
Cheese Soup
 New York–Style Pizza
New York–Style Pizza
 Bananas Foster
Bananas Foster
 Coleslaw
Coleslaw
 Chicken fingers
Chicken fingers
 Cheeseburgers
Cheeseburgers
 Mozzarella sticks
Mozzarella sticks
 Buffalo wings
Buffalo wings
 Lobster rolls
Lobster rolls

Restaurant features in Sayville

Cities near Sayville

New York City
New York City

77k restaurants

West Sayville
West Sayville

65 restaurants

Bayport
Bayport

76 restaurants

West New York
West New York

10k restaurants

Patchogue
Patchogue

389 restaurants

Bohemia
Bohemia

166 restaurants

Filters

Location

Location

  • Current location

Types

Rating

Opening hours

Search radius

Any distance
Any distance
0.2 mi
0.5 mi
1 mi
2 mi
5 mi
10 mi
20 mi
50 mi
75 mi
Price

Dishes

Features

Cuisines

Top 7 restaurants in Sayville

75 restaurants 75 restaurants
Rating
Rating
Distance
Distance/rating
Popularity
Michelin
Trip
Frommer's
Zomato
Google
Foursquare
Opentable
Yandex
Current location
Point on map
Sayville city center
.
Rating
Rating
Distance
Distance/rating
Popularity
Michelin
Trip
Frommer's
Zomato
Google
Foursquare
Opentable
Yandex
Note: 80 non-restaurant eating places are hidden. Show all

Other results

Redefine Meals

1. Redefine Meals

 Restaurant, Fast food
5 879 votes
$$$$
Open until 10PM
Butera's

2. Butera's

 Restaurant, Seafood, Italian
4.8 3638 votes
$$$$
Closed until 4PM
Italian, American, Pizza, Seafood, Wine bars, Vegetarian options
normal ... area stop in I wouldn’t travel to it but it’s a good local restaurant 
The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

3. The Wayward Kitchen & Cocktails

 Restaurant, Seafood, Pub & bar
4.8 837 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
Cocktail bars, Dessert, Salads, Vegetarian options
excellent ... salad, and German spaetzle with autumn vegetables were magnificent. The 
Koi Sushi

4. Koi Sushi

 Sushi, Restaurant
4.6 365 votes
$$$$
Open until 9:30PM
Sushi, Asian, Chinese, Japanese, Vegetarian options
Off The Block Kitchen & Meats

5. Off The Block Kitchen & Meats

 New American restaurant, Steakhouse
4.8 1936 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
excellent ... Block is hands down the best butcher and restaurant around - there is no 
The Cull House

6. The Cull House

 Restaurant, Seafood, Pub & bar
4.8 2049 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
Seafood, Fast food, Wine bars, Beer bars, Vegetarian options
excellent Restaurant Review: The Cull House – A Hidden Gem on Long Island Tucked away 
Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

7. Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

 Cafe, Restaurant, Seafood
4.9 1870 votes
$$$$
Open until 9:30PM
New American, American, Fusion, Italian, Vegetarian options
normal Arrived at opening on a Friday 
Local Burger - Sayville - Restaurant and Bar

8. Local Burger - Sayville - Restaurant and Bar

 Restaurant, Pub & bar, BBQ, Desserts
2.2 88 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
Barbecue, Fast food, New American, Vegetarian options
bad Very poorly ran restaurant, food was not good, also way to overpriced 
T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville)

9. T.O.A. Asian Fusion (Sayville)

 Restaurant, Sushi
4.5 649 votes
$$$$
Open until 9:15PM
Sushi, Chinese, Asian, Japanese, Vegetarian options
excellent Fantastic place to eat 
Mallory Square Restaurant and Bar

10. Mallory Square Restaurant and Bar

 American restaurant, Pub & bar
3.3 82 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
excellent If you re taking the Sayville Ferry to Fire Island then you ll be pretty 
Blackbirds' Grille

11. Blackbirds' Grille

 Seafood, Restaurant, Pub & bar
4.3 1984 votes
$$$$
Open until 10PM
Cajun, Creole, Fast food, American, Southern, Vegetarian options
Parlor House Grill

12. Parlor House Grill

 American restaurant, BBQ
3.5 807 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
excellent Nice homey restaurant. ... Good appetizer and drinks 
YOYO CHICKEN ( BOHEMIA )

13. YOYO CHICKEN ( BOHEMIA )

 Fast food, Restaurant
4.8 106 votes
$$$$
Open until 2AM
Sayville Pizza & Metros on main Italian Restaurant

14. Sayville Pizza & Metros on main Italian Restaurant

 Restaurant, Pizzeria, Italian
3.5 515 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
Italian, Pizza, Dessert, Wine bars, Vegetarian options
excellent ... perfect little restaurant! with Sayville Pizza 
Aegean Cafe

15. Aegean Cafe

 Cafe, Restaurant
3.2 876 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
Greek, Mediterranean, Vegetarian options
excellent As always the best food, great service and the owner hands on 
Metros on Main

16. Metros on Main

 Restaurant, Pizzeria, Pub & bar, Italian
4.5 111 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
Italian, Pizza, Spanish, Salads, Vegetarian options
excellent Metros is like the Cheers of Sayville 
The Sayville Inn

17. The Sayville Inn

 Seafood, Restaurant, Pub & bar
2.8 867 votes
$$$$
Closed until tomorrow
American, Seafood, Fast food, Vegetarian options
excellent This place is great 
Jade Garden

18. Jade Garden

 Chinese, Chinese restaurant
3.4 134 votes
$$$$
Closed until tomorrow
excellent Best Chinese restaurant around hands down! It’ 
Canz Bar & Grill

19. Canz Bar & Grill

 Pub & bar, Restaurant, BBQ, Beer bar
4 266 votes
$$$$
Open until 12AM
American, Beer bars, Vegetarian options
normal Our waitress was drunk soo that was an experience 
Sayville Athletic Club

20. Sayville Athletic Club

 Club, Pub & bar, Restaurant
4.3 137 votes
$$$$
Open until 12AM
Fast food, Sandwiches, Vegetarian options
avatar Advisor Pierre