Add a photo
35 photos
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Delicious food is a recipe for success of this cafe, its bagel sandwiches are good. Based on the reviewers' opinions, waiters serve nicely cooked bagels here. You will be offered delicious coffee.
The Eccentric Bagel is rated on Google 4.8 by its guests.
Best in the city
This award is based on the analysis of multiple factors, including reviews, ratings, and user engagement trends on Restaurant Guru.Desserts
Frequently mentioned in reviews
See allLess
Visitors' reviews on The Eccentric Bagel
/ 71
Add your review
Request content removal
Matt Miller
2 months ago on Google
Outstanding spot! And the best bagels on the entire East End without a doubt. Stumbled upon Eccentric Bagel finally today and absolutely loved it and Darren the owner. Great local spot, great menu and vibes, and they actually have gluten free as well! Splurged on real bagels though and they were all delicious. Shoutout ! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5
Request content removal
Millie Kwan
a year ago on Google
On our crusade for the best NY style bagel on LI, we stopped at The Eccentric Bagel on the way to the Hamptons from the North Fork. One of the best bagels that we had while in Long Island. The crust was crackly, the crumb was dense and chewy...in short these were some of the best bagels. I will say that the breakfast bagel sandwiches are huge and should be shared. Definitely would stop for a bagel if you're in Shelter Island.
M
Request content removal
Marc
3 years ago on Restaurant Guru
I asked the old woman there for a quarter pound of turkey. First she said no. I asked her why not? And she said only for sandwiches. I explained to her I am on a no carb diet and can't have breaD. She said she's not cutting. I guess it's pre-cut. So I asked for a turkey sandwich with no bread. She insisted to order turkey on a plate -Which I did. There is an electric sign up in the place that lists all the deli meats by the pound. I pointed that out to her and she told me she's understaffed. There were 4 people behind the counter. We were her only customers at the time. We had our staff shirts on. We are obviously not residents. I know she would not have treated us like this if we were from here.
1
0
|
Reply
All reviews
ClosedOpens at 7AM tomorrow
$$$$
Price range per person $10 - $25
© OpenStreetMap
contributions
Address
25 W Neck Rd, Shelter Island, New York, USA
Features
Outdoor seating
Parking
Takeaway
Wheelchair accessible
Сredit cards accepted
Opening hours
| SundaySun | 7AM-2PM |
| MondayMon | Closed |
| TuesdayTue | 7AM-2PM |
| WednesdayWed | 7AM-2PM |
| ThursdayThu | 7AM-2PM |
| FridayFri | 7AM-2PM |
| SaturdaySat | 7AM-3PM |
Website
