The Old Grist Mill Tavern

The Old Grist Mill Tavern, located in Seekonk, offers classic American pub-style fare in a charming, Hallmark Christmas movie-esque atmosphere. The establishment's mid-1980s menu may not be amazing, but the homemade dressings on the salad bar and the delicious cinnamon loaf are noteworthy. The prices are on the higher side, especially for the $18 salad bar, which is only included with entrees. However, the cozy decor, complete with exposed wooden beams, plaid carpets, and a large stone fireplace, makes up for it.

The prime rib and chicken dishes are good, while the burgers are average and not worth the $22 price tag. The seafood dishes are full of butter and cream and can leave one feeling a bit heavy after eating. The staff is friendly and attentive, with servers like Jason receiving high praise from patrons.

The establishment features a bar/lounge area with comfortable chairs and a draft beer selection that could use some improvement. The private basement room is perfect for larger parties, while the main dining room boasts views of the waterfall and pond, which are lit up at night.

The menu may feel old-fashioned, but it offers something for everyone, including baked stuffed shrimp, beef wellington, and crabcakes. The establishment also has a salad bar, which is rare to find in restaurants these days. Cocktails, soft drinks, and wines are available, with the pistachio latte being a standout option.

Overall, The Old Grist Mill Tavern is a fine dining spot that offers a cozy ambiance and classic American dishes. It may not be perfect, but it is worth a visit for the experience alone.