Find best restaurants! For business
Search
Where:

Restaurants in Fire Island

Kabuki Sushi

Kabuki Sushi

4.9 478 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Asian
Sushi 1 Restaurant

Sushi 1 Restaurant

4.9 269 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Seafood, Asian
Mykonos Greek Restaurant

Mykonos Greek Restaurant

4.9 657 votes
$$$$
Greek, Mediterranean
Tomo

Tomo

4.9 375 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Japanese
George Martin's Strip Steak

George Martin's Strip Steak

4.9 5777 votes
$$$$
Seafood, Steakhouses, American, Wine bars, Cocktail bars
Goccia D'Oro

Goccia D'Oro

4.9 756 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza
Aji 53 Services

Aji 53 Services

4.9 1226 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Asian, New American, Soups
Dah Lee Restaurant

Dah Lee Restaurant

4.9 451 votes
$$$$
Chinese, Asian
Chop Shop Bar and Grill

Chop Shop Bar and Grill

4.9 2337 votes
$$$$
American, New American, Seafood
Feng Yi Chinese Restaurant

Feng Yi Chinese Restaurant

4.9 298 votes
$$$$
Chinese
The Patio

The Patio

4.9 1850 votes
$$$$
American, Italian, New American, Wine bars
Doc Lee Lau Chinese Restaurant

Doc Lee Lau Chinese Restaurant

4.9 369 votes
$$$$
Chinese, New American
Le Dock

Le Dock

4.9 474 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American, Cocktail bars
Cusmos Greek American Restaurant

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant

4.9 617 votes
$$$$
Greek
Old Street Restaurant and Bar

Old Street Restaurant and Bar

4.9 1220 votes
$$$$
American, Fast food, Seafood
Southside Fish and Clam

Southside Fish and Clam

4.9 2254 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American
Alletto's Restaurant

Alletto's Restaurant

4.9 347 votes
$$$$
Italian, Seafood, New American
Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant

Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant

4.9 912 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Salads
Sand Castle

Sand Castle

4.9 850 votes
$$$$
New American, Seafood, American
BayVue

BayVue

4.9 2298 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American, New American, Cocktail bars

Food delivery in Fire Island

Tonino's Pizza

Tonino's Pizza

4.9 627 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Dominick's Pizza & Pasta

Dominick's Pizza & Pasta

4.9 311 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Kabuki Sushi

Kabuki Sushi

4.9 478 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Asian
Spassos Pizzeria

Spassos Pizzeria

4.9 767 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Lung Hing Kitchen

Lung Hing Kitchen

4.9 127 votes
$$$$
Chinese
Doc Lee Lau Chinese Restaurant

Doc Lee Lau Chinese Restaurant

4.9 369 votes
$$$$
Chinese, New American
Dah Lee Restaurant

Dah Lee Restaurant

4.9 451 votes
$$$$
Chinese, Asian
Pigs on a Wing

Pigs on a Wing

4.9 502 votes
$$$$
Fast food, Southern, Barbecue, Sandwiches
Mary's Pizza and Pasta

Mary's Pizza and Pasta

4.9 1808 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Mr. G’s Pizzeria

Mr. G’s Pizzeria

4.9 415 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian, Dessert, Salads
Empire Ginger

Empire Ginger

4.8 172 votes
$$$$
Chinese, Thai, Asian
New Empire

New Empire

4.9 112 votes
$$$$
Chinese
Sachem Delicatessen and Restaurant

Sachem Delicatessen and Restaurant

4.9 242 votes
$$$$
Delis, Sandwiches
Cusmos Greek American Restaurant

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant

4.9 617 votes
$$$$
Greek
Felico's Catering

Felico's Catering

4.9 283 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Aji 53 Services

Aji 53 Services

4.9 1226 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Asian, New American, Soups
Salsa Salsa of Smithtown

Salsa Salsa of Smithtown

4.9 748 votes
$$$$
Mexican, Latin American
Monte’s Pizzeria

Monte’s Pizzeria

4.9 200 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Tomo

Tomo

4.9 375 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Japanese
Eddies Pizza

Eddies Pizza

4.9 283 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian

Takeaway restaurants in Fire Island

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant

Cusmos Greek American Restaurant

4.9 617 votes
$$$$
Greek
Feng Yi Chinese Restaurant

Feng Yi Chinese Restaurant

4.9 298 votes
$$$$
Chinese
Kabuki Sushi

Kabuki Sushi

4.9 478 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Asian
Sushi 1 Restaurant

Sushi 1 Restaurant

4.9 269 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Seafood, Asian
Tonino's Pizza

Tonino's Pizza

4.9 627 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Mary's Pizza and Pasta

Mary's Pizza and Pasta

4.9 1808 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Tomo

Tomo

4.9 375 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Japanese
Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant

Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant

4.9 912 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Salads
Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

4.9 1449 votes
$$$$
New American
Boom Burger

Boom Burger

4.9 1243 votes
$$$$
Fast food, American
New Empire

New Empire

4.9 112 votes
$$$$
Chinese
Pigs on a Wing

Pigs on a Wing

4.9 502 votes
$$$$
Fast food, Southern, Barbecue, Sandwiches
Hing Hing Kitchen

Hing Hing Kitchen

4.9 283 votes
$$$$
Chinese
Firehouse Pizza

Firehouse Pizza

4.9 96 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Brunetti Pizza Westhampton Beach

Brunetti Pizza Westhampton Beach

4.9 482 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Aji 53 Services

Aji 53 Services

4.9 1226 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Asian, New American, Soups
Dah Lee Restaurant

Dah Lee Restaurant

4.9 451 votes
$$$$
Chinese, Asian
Salsa Salsa of Smithtown

Salsa Salsa of Smithtown

4.9 748 votes
$$$$
Mexican, Latin American
Doc Lee Lau Chinese Restaurant

Doc Lee Lau Chinese Restaurant

4.9 369 votes
$$$$
Chinese, New American
FUNCHOS certified tacologist

FUNCHOS certified tacologist

4.9 343 votes
$$$$
Mexican

Seafood restaurants in Fire Island

Southside Fish and Clam

Southside Fish and Clam

4.9 2254 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American
George Martin's Strip Steak

George Martin's Strip Steak

4.9 5777 votes
$$$$
Seafood, Steakhouses, American, Wine bars, Cocktail bars
BayVue

BayVue

4.9 2298 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American, New American, Cocktail bars
Alletto's Restaurant

Alletto's Restaurant

4.9 347 votes
$$$$
Italian, Seafood, New American
Le Dock

Le Dock

4.9 474 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American, Cocktail bars
The Patio

The Patio

4.9 1850 votes
$$$$
American, Italian, New American, Wine bars
Sand Castle

Sand Castle

4.9 850 votes
$$$$
New American, Seafood, American
Chop Shop Bar and Grill

Chop Shop Bar and Grill

4.9 2337 votes
$$$$
American, New American, Seafood
Sushi 1 Restaurant

Sushi 1 Restaurant

4.9 269 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Seafood, Asian
Tiki Joe's at Captree Boat Basin

Tiki Joe's at Captree Boat Basin

4.8 98 votes
$$$$
Seafood
Schooner Inn

Schooner Inn

4.9 1306 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American, Italian
Pines Bistro

Pines Bistro

4.9 98 votes
$$$$
Italian
Dive

Dive

4.9 147 votes
$$$$
New American
Casino Cafe

Casino Cafe

4.9 52 votes
$$$$
American, Seafood
Kabuki Sushi

Kabuki Sushi

4.9 478 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Asian
Aji 53 Services

Aji 53 Services

4.9 1226 votes
$$$$
Japanese, Sushi, Asian, New American, Soups
Garden Grill

Garden Grill

4.9 1106 votes
$$$$
American, Seafood, Cocktail bars
Tomo

Tomo

4.9 375 votes
$$$$
Sushi, Japanese
Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

Joelle - Barroom + Cafe

4.9 1449 votes
$$$$
New American
Kismet Inn

Kismet Inn

4.9 512 votes
$$$$
American

Pizza restaurants in Fire Island

Spassos Pizzeria

Spassos Pizzeria

4.9 767 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Brunetti Pizza Westhampton Beach

Brunetti Pizza Westhampton Beach

4.9 482 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Tonino's Pizza

Tonino's Pizza

4.9 627 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Mary's Pizza and Pasta

Mary's Pizza and Pasta

4.9 1808 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Cherry Grove Pizza

Cherry Grove Pizza

4.9 287 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Salads, Sandwiches
Dominick's Pizza & Pasta

Dominick's Pizza & Pasta

4.9 311 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Monte’s Pizzeria

Monte’s Pizzeria

4.9 200 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant

Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant

4.9 912 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza, Salads
Mr. G’s Pizzeria

Mr. G’s Pizzeria

4.9 415 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian, Dessert, Salads
Eddies Pizza

Eddies Pizza

4.9 283 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Pines Pizza

Pines Pizza

4.9 50 votes
$$$$
Pizza
Pizza Shack of Kismet

Pizza Shack of Kismet

4.9 103 votes
$$$$
Pizza
Buona Sera

Buona Sera

4.9 598 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza
Firehouse Pizza

Firehouse Pizza

4.9 96 votes
$$$$
Pizza, Italian
Schooner Inn

Schooner Inn

4.9 1306 votes
$$$$
Seafood, American, Italian
So Tastee Eatery

So Tastee Eatery

4.9 32 votes
$$$$
Pizza
Grove Pizza

Grove Pizza

4.8 28 votes
$$$$
Beach Street Pizza & Grille

Beach Street Pizza & Grille

4 votes
$$$$
Pizza
Surfside Pizza

Surfside Pizza

Pizza
Goccia D'Oro

Goccia D'Oro

4.9 756 votes
$$$$
Italian, Pizza

Tasty dishes in Fire Island

Cheese Soup
Cheese Soup
 New York–Style Pizza
New York–Style Pizza
 Angel Food Cake
Angel Food Cake
 Succotash
Succotash
 Cheeseburgers
Cheeseburgers
 Hamburgers
Hamburgers
 Lobster rolls
Lobster rolls

Restaurant features in Fire Island

Cities near Fire Island

New York City
New York City

75k restaurants

Ocean Beach
Ocean Beach

46 restaurants

West New York
West New York

10k restaurants

Bay Shore
Bay Shore

449 restaurants

Yonkers
Yonkers

2k restaurants

Islip
Islip

176 restaurants

Filters

Location

Location

  • Current location

Types

Rating

Opening hours

Search radius

Any distance
Any distance
0.2 mi
0.5 mi
1 mi
2 mi
5 mi
10 mi
20 mi
50 mi
75 mi
Price

Dishes

Features

Cuisines

Top 7 restaurants in Fire Island

88 restaurants 88 restaurants
Rating
Rating
Distance
Distance/rating
Popularity
Michelin
Trip
Frommer's
Zomato
Google
Foursquare
Opentable
Yandex
Current location
Point on map
Fire Island city center
.
Rating
Rating
Distance
Distance/rating
Popularity
Michelin
Trip
Frommer's
Zomato
Google
Foursquare
Opentable
Yandex
Note: 75 non-restaurant eating places are hidden. Show all

Other results

George Martin's Strip Steak

1. George Martin's Strip Steak

 Restaurant, Seafood, Steakhouse, Pub & bar
4.8 6003 votes
$$$$
Closed until 4:30PM
Seafood, American, Wine bars, Cocktail bars, Vegetarian options
excellent This was my first time and I really loved it. The food is very good 
Chop Shop Bar and Grill

2. Chop Shop Bar and Grill

 Pub & bar, Restaurant, Seafood, BBQ, Steakhouse
4.8 2486 votes
$$$$
Closed until 4PM
American, New American, Seafood, Vegetarian options
Dive

3. Dive

 New American restaurant, Seafood, Pub & bar, Sushi
4.8 273 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
normal Pretty average Fire Island eatery 
Mykonos Greek Restaurant

4. Mykonos Greek Restaurant

 Restaurant, Cafe
4.3 632 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
Greek, Mediterranean, Vegetarian options
excellent 02/08/2022. Tuesday evening. Superb Greek 
Le Dock

5. Le Dock

 Restaurant, Seafood, Pub & bar
3.7 488 votes
$$$$
Closed until 5PM
Seafood, American, Cocktail bars, Vegetarian options
excellent You will not find a restaurant on fire Island that is better 
Tomo

6. Tomo

 Restaurant, Sushi
3.5 425 votes
$$$$
Open until 10PM
excellent ... UPDATE 10/2022. This You can make any roll withou 
Dah Lee Restaurant

7. Dah Lee Restaurant

 Restaurant, Chinese
3.2 498 votes
$$$$
Open until 11PM
Chinese, Asian, Vegetarian options
excellent Dah Lee is very good, another Chinese food gem in Suffolk county, the sweet 
Samui Thai @Fire Island

8. Samui Thai @Fire Island

 Thai restaurant
2.9 36 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
excellent From the moment we walked into Samui Thai restaurant We were greeted with 
Feng Yi Chinese Restaurant

9. Feng Yi Chinese Restaurant

 Chinese restaurant, Chinese
2.8 349 votes
$$$$
Open until 11PM
excellent Best Chinese restaurant in the area , fair prices, free extras when you 
Sand Castle

10. Sand Castle

 Restaurant, Pub & bar, Seafood
2.9 886 votes
$$$$
Open until 11PM
New American, Seafood, American, Vegetarian options
normal Lovely 39th anniversary dinner seated outside near the ocean boardwalk but 
Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant

11. Mannino's Pizzeria Restaurant

 Restaurant, Pizzeria, Italian
4.5 983 votes
$$$$
Open until 10PM
Italian, Pizza, Salads, Vegetarian options
Old Street Restaurant and Bar

12. Old Street Restaurant and Bar

 Pub & bar, Restaurant
3.4 1256 votes
$$$$
Open until 10PM
American, Fast food, Seafood, Vegetarian options
excellent Very nice restaurant/pub with a bar area and separate dining room 
Joe's American Grill

13. Joe's American Grill

 BBQ, Restaurant, Seafood, Steakhouse
3.9 266 votes
$$$$
Closed until 4PM
American, Fast food, Salads
excellent In Westhampton Beach for the weekend and had dinner at Joe s American Grill 
Top of the Bay Bistro

14. Top of the Bay Bistro

 Restaurant, Seafood
3.9 530 votes
$$$$
Closed until 5PM
American, New American
excellent Many wonderful things can be said about this restaurant 
Fire Island Beach House

15. Fire Island Beach House

 Restaurant, Pub & bar, BBQ
2.9 196 votes
No info on opening hours
normal With this hotel, you re paying for the LOCATION 
Cherry's On The Bay

16. Cherry's On The Bay

 Restaurant, Pub & bar
4.8 696 votes
$$$$
Open until 1AM
Cocktail bars, American
normal This is for the restaurant/food only 
Parador Latino

17. Parador Latino

 Colombian restaurant
3.2 716 votes
$$$$
Open until 9:30PM
excellent A beautiful restaurant 
Caribeno Restaurant Incorporated

18. Caribeno Restaurant Incorporated

 Restaurant
4.2 373 votes
$$$$
Open until 9PM
Caribbean, Spanish, Dominican, Latin American
excellent Very good food, excellent service and polite staff, be careful not to pay 
Island Breeze

19. Island Breeze

 Restaurant, Seafood, Pub & bar
2.6 297 votes
$$$$
Open until 10PM
American, Seafood, Sandwiches, Vegetarian options
bad Hungry for dinner, we went (Thursday 7/17 around 7:30pm) to Island Breeze 
Casino Cafe

20. Casino Cafe

 Cafe, Pub & bar, Restaurant, Seafood
3.9 63 votes
$$$$
Closed until 4:30PM
American, Seafood, Steakhouses, Vegetarian options
avatar Advisor Pierre