Mariner’s Inn

Name: Mariner’s Inn
Address: 5339 Lighthouse Bay Dr, Madison, Wisconsin, USA
Telephone: +16082463120
Price range: $$$
Rating: 4.1

Permanently closed

Steakhouse in Madison

3480 votes

Permanently closed

All photos Food Interior Exterior Drink Dessert

Add a photo

234 photos

Check out how Mariner’s Inn looks inside

Take a seat at one of the tables at Mariner’s Inn

Mariner’s Inn is distinguished by interior and beverage

Try nicely cooked fried seafood, salmon fillet and breaded fish. The truth is that you will really like tasty lemon pie, fruitcake and crumble. Get your meal started with good michelada, house wine or martinis. A lot of visitors order delicious bread drink.

Food delivery is a big plus of this steakhouse. Cheerful employees work hard, stay positive and make this place great. The fine service displays a high level of quality at Mariner’s Inn. Prices here are reported to be reasonable. There is a nice club atmosphere and modern fireplace at this place. Google gives it 4.4 so you can choose this spot to spend a good time here.

Best in the city

A top 10 best restaurant in Madison (2025)

Frequently mentioned in reviews

surf and Turf

traditional Wisconsin supper

au gratin potatoes

lobster Tail

hash Browns

bruschetta

cheese Curds

salmon Florentine

steakhouse

walleye

See allLess

Ratings of Mariner’s Inn

Zomato

Foursquare

Google

Trip

(3.9/5)

119

Facebook

Opentable

Visitors' reviews on Mariner’s Inn

/ 1650

Search visitors’ reviews

Add your review

Request content removal

rogette koby a year ago on Google

One of Madison's best staples! Sad that the end of the journey is almost here. Glad we got to enjoy it one more time! The von Rutenberg's are really tremendous people and I hope they all enjoy retirement! Price per person: $50–100 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Response from the owner a year ago

Thank you for the awesome 5 star review! We thank you for your patronage through the years.

Show replies (1)

Request content removal

Paul Herford a year ago on Google

Chose this place as an early Father’s Day dinner with the parents and grandma. Service was punctual, having us seated within a couple minutes of our reservation time. Waitresses were pleasant and attentive, and the food- incredible. (These pumpernickel steakhouse rolls are on another level!) Great experience with the parents, perfect atmosphere, and quality establishment all around. Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Response from the owner a year ago

Thank you for the awesome 5 star review and we are so glad that you enjoyed your Father's Day dinner. I was there too. It was an awesome evening.

Show replies (1)

Request content removal

Joel Fugere a year ago on Google

Very good menu, the front of the house bar is a little in the way but not terrible, the interior is older but good old and well maintained, unfortunately we were told that it will be closing soon, to be turned into some apartments, a marina and a bar. Price per person: $20–30 Food: 4 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

Response from the owner a year ago

Thank you for your great review. We appreciate your patronage.

Show replies (1)

All reviews

+1 608-246-3120

American , Seafood , Steakhouses