Rye Restaurant

Name: Rye Restaurant
Address: 308 W College Ave, Appleton, Wisconsin, USA
Telephone: +19203804745
Price range: $$$
Rating: 4.8

2174 votes

#10 of 445 restaurants in Appleton

ClosedOpens at 12PM

Updated 19 days ago

All photos and videos Videos Food Interior Drink Dessert Exterior

Add a photo

491 photos

Enjoy the view at the outside area of Rye Restaurant

Fox Trot Trail is a great attraction for tourists who come to eat at this restaurant after long walks. Good fried oysters, salmon appetizers and beet salads are the tastiest dishes. Try tasty ice cream, chocolate cakes and brulee dessert. After a long working day, you can try delicious marsala, bourbon or irish stout. In accordance with the visitors' opinions, waiters serve good bread drink or good tea.

It's easy to find Rye Restaurant due to the great location. Most guests find the staff nice. Service at this place is something one can name fast. According to the guests' opinions, prices are average. The homey decor and calm atmosphere let clients feel relaxed here. As for the Google rating, this spot got 4.6.

Frequently mentioned in reviews

bone-In Duroc Pork

pan Seared Atlantic Scallops

new England Style

jonathan

mushroom ragu

aged Cheddar

beer Braised Short

cheese Curds

bacon Risotto Balls

chicken Marsala

See allLess

Ratings of Rye Restaurant

Zomato

Foursquare

Google

Trip

(4.3/5)

228

Facebook

(4.7/5)

Opentable

(4.8/5)

810

Visitors' reviews on Rye Restaurant

/ 1461

Search visitors’ reviews

Add your review

Request content removal

Christopher Rosenfelt a month ago on Google

Great food, but the server was not good. She rarely smiles, did not check in on us enough and generally seemed like she didn't want to be there. Even if she doesn't want to be there, sometimes you gotta fake it. I forgot her name but she has short blonde hair. We also didn't like the little booths with strange side by side seating. We'd like to face each other while talking. Food: 4 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 2 Order type: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30

Request content removal

Alex Walsh 5 months ago on Google

We had an incredible dinner at Rye Restaurant and left raving about every single bite! This stylish urban-rustic spot in Appleton, perfect ambiance with dim lighting, candles, and that cozy yet upscale vibe next to the CopperLeaf Hotel. I ordered the special cowboy steak (what a beauty!), and it was cooked to perfection: juicy, flavorful, with a gorgeous sear, topped with those rich, glazed mushrooms and onions, resting on creamy mashed potatoes with tender carrots. The presentation was restaurant-level stunning, and the flavors were spot on tender, savory, and comforting all at once. My wife got the lemon chicken, which looked and tasted amazing: perfectly seared chicken medallions with bright lemon notes, capers, grilled lemon slices, and a pile of crisp green beans over mashed potatoes. It was fresh, zesty, and beautifully balanced. We finished with their chocolate dessert, a rich, decadent torte with fresh berries, whipped cream, mint, and that gorgeous berry sauce drizzle. Absolute heaven and the ideal sweet ending! The service was attentive and knowledgeable, the cocktails (if you had any) are always craft level, and everything felt fresh and locally inspired. We loved literally everything about the meal… except we were a little sad the wedge salad wasn’t available anymore and hope it is brought back! Rye never disappoints, highly recommend for a special night out in the Fox Cities. We’ll be back soon (and crossing our fingers for that wedge salad next time)! Thanks for the memorable evening, Rye team! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $70–80

Request content removal

Denise Ottman a year ago on Restaurant Guru

We’ve dined at Rye before and have always enjoyed it, which is why we chose it to celebrate a birthday on April 14th. I made a reservation and mentioned we were celebrating a special occasion, hoping the team might help make it a bit more memorable.

Arriving at the bar early, to start with a cocktail the bartender was carrying on a conversation with another guest on the other side of the bar which made us feel unimportant & insignificant; which isn't the tone I was accustomed to

There was a small birthday note on the table, which was a nice touch. However, unlike what we've experienced at many other upscale restaurants, there was no acknowledgment of the birthday during or after the meal. Even a small gesture—like a dessert —would have made a big difference. I would have gladly paid for a celebratory treat, so this wasn’t about expecting something complimentary.

It felt awkward to bring it up in the moment, but I left feeling a bit let down for choosing Rye to mark the occasion. Hopefully, this feedback can help improve the experience for future celebrations.

0 0 | Reply

All reviews

+1 920-380-4745

Book

American, Cocktail bars, Vegetarian options

$$$$ Price range per person $30-$80