Add a photo
124 photos
Add a photo
Add your opinion
Eating perfectly cooked lobster ravioli, tuna and duck is a pleasant experience here. Order good key lime pie, gelato and cheesecakes at this bar when you happen to be near it. Based on the reviewers' opinions, waiters serve delicious martinis or good wine. Here you may drink good coffee.
Live music is played by musicians in the evening. The well-trained staff reflects the style and character of Surfside Inn. Fine service is something that visitors highlight in their reviews. You may be surprised by affordable prices at this place. It's usually good to try something new, enjoying the lovely atmosphere. This spot scored 4.5 in the Google rating system.
Frequently mentioned in reviews
See allLess
Visitors' reviews on Surfside Inn
/ 45
Add your review
S
Request content removal
Shana Devlin
5 months ago on Google
This is a review for the restaurant! We had a fantastic meal here. Our server was friendly and attentive. Ambiance was quiet and relaxing. We had a great table with a beautiful view of the ocean (and we even saw whales jumping out of the water)! The food was fresh and delicious. We had the Caesar salad & tomato mozzarella salad to start and the shrimp pasta & ribeye steak special for our mains. While it wasn’t a cheap meal, we were prepared and happy to pay for the high quality meal we had. We’ll definitely be back! Service: 5
L
Request content removal
Lida Breezee
6 months ago on Google
My husband and I celebrated our 32nd wedding anniversary at Surfside on 7/11. Take my word for itThe food was probably the best we’ve had in Mtk. The staff was wonderful and friendly and they gave us champagne to celebrate while looking at the spectacular view of the ocean. I highly recommend to those who are looking for a place to celebrate an anniversary, a girls night, date night, bday celebration or just for drinks & apps. Great place!! Service: 5
M
Request content removal
Michelle Civetta
2 years ago on Google
My family and I have been customers of Surfside Inn Restaurant for many years -either for lunch and/or dinner. When we arrived, we were puzzled as to why there was a valet when the lot is so small. The food was good, but prices were too expensive in our opinion, i.e. $37- $40+ for pasta dishes. Drinks seemed overpriced as well. Sadly, we decided not to return in the future.
S
Response from the owner
2 years ago
We have a Valet for that exact reason. We do not have a large parking lot but do have access to parking in the back of the business. A Valet is is needed to maximize our space. Prices reflect the quality of the products used (Prime …We have a Valet for that exact reason. We do not have a large parking lot but do have access to parking in the back of the business. A Valet is is needed to maximize our space. Prices reflect the quality of the products used (Prime Meats, Fresh Fish) as well as the size of our portions. Also drinks are oversized compared to most restaurants.More
Show replies (1)
All reviews
© OpenStreetMap
contributions
Address
685 Old Montauk Hwy, Montauk, New York, USA
Features
Outdoor seating
Parking
Booking
TV
Opening hours
| SundaySun | 10AM-11PM |
| MondayMon | 5PM-10PM |
| TuesdayTue | 5PM-10PM |
| WednesdayWed | 5PM-10PM |
| ThursdayThu | 5PM-10PM |
| FridayFri | 5PM-10PM |
| SaturdaySat | 12PM-11PM |
Website
