Find the best place to eat in Bay Shore, spring 2024

All restaurants

Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge $$$$

#1 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9:30PM

Pecado Mexican $$$$

#2 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Mexican

Open until 10PM

Butera's - Bay Shore $$$$

#3 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 9PM

Lakehouse $$$$

#4 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

New American

Open until 9:30PM

The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails $$$$

#5 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Cocktail bars

Closed until Tuesday

JBBQ Hot Pot & BBQ $$$$

#6 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Barbecue

Open until 9PM

Aji 53 Japanese Restaurant $$$$

#7 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9:55PM

Mitsui Japanese Restaurant $$$$

#8 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Japanese

May be permanently closed

Sumou Sushi & Hibachi $$$$

#9 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9:30PM

Salt & Barrel $$$$

#10 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

Open until 8PM

ITA Kitchen $$$$

#11 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 9PM

Galanga $$$$

#12 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Thai

Open until 10PM

Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering $$$$

#13 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

American

Open until 8:30PM

King's Chophouse $$$$

#14 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Steakhouses

Open until 9PM

Takeshi Sushi Teriyaki $$$$

#15 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9PM

Bella Vie $$$$

#16 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 9PM

White Cap Fish Market & Seafood Restaurant $$$$

#17 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

Closed until tomorrow

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant $$$$

#18 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 10PM

Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge $$$$

#19 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

Japanese

May be permanently closed

Whalers $$$$

#20 of 237 restaurants in Bay Shore

American

Open until 5:30PM

All restaurants

Peter Pan Diner $$$$

#12 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

American

Open until 11PM

Bo Wah Kitchen $$$$

#90 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Chinese

Open until 9:30PM

Amore Pizza $$$$

#36 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 9PM

Local Burger - Bay Shore Restaurant and Bar $$$$

#56 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Fast food

Open until 9:30PM

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore $$$$

#13 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 8PM

Buseto Pizza $$$$

#42 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 9:30PM

Zest $$$$

#1 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 8PM

Tap Room $$$$

#29 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

American

Open until 12AM

Sumou Sushi & Hibachi $$$$

#30 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9:30PM

La Casa $$$$

#52 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Italian

May be permanently closed

Flour Shoppe Cafe $$$$

#77 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Closed until tomorrow

Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant $$$$

#80 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 9PM

Domino's Pizza $$$$

#114 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 12AM

Migueleño Restaurant $$$$

#134 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Spanish

Open until 10PM

Paradise Taste China $$$$

#154 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Chinese

May be permanently closed

Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge $$$$

#4 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9:30PM

Aji 53 Japanese Restaurant $$$$

#19 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9:55PM

Galanga $$$$

#27 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Thai

Open until 10PM

Fratelli Pizzeria $$$$

#38 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 10PM

Golden Star $$$$

#66 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Chinese

Open until 9PM

All restaurants

Galanga $$$$

#27 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Thai

Open until 10PM

KTO Cuisine $$$$

#2 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Latin American

Open until 7:30PM

Savor Eatery $$$$

#11 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Vietnamese

May be permanently closed

Mediterranean Express - Powered by The Greek $$$$

#17 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Greek

Closed until tomorrow

Nicky's On the Bay $$$$

#75 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Seafood

Open until 10PM

Peking Kitchen $$$$

#78 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Chinese

Open until 9:30PM

Khyber Grill & Gyro $$$$

#106 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Indian

Open until 10PM

Number 1 Chinese Kitchen $$$$

#149 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Chinese

Open until 8:30PM

Homemade Chinese Kitchen $$$$

#186 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Chinese

May be permanently closed

Takumi Sushi Hibachi & Lounge $$$$

#4 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9:30PM

Peter Pan Diner $$$$

#12 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

American

Open until 11PM

Aji 53 Japanese Restaurant $$$$

#19 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9:55PM

Mulberry Street Bay Shore $$$$

#28 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 8:30PM

Takeshi Sushi Teriyaki $$$$

#49 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9PM

Local Burger - Bay Shore Restaurant and Bar $$$$

#56 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Fast food

Open until 9:30PM

Bo Wah Kitchen $$$$

#90 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Chinese

Open until 9:30PM

Zest $$$$

#1 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 8PM

Tula Kitchen $$$$

#21 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Vegetarian

Closed until Tuesday

Sumou Sushi & Hibachi $$$$

#30 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9:30PM

Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge $$$$

#55 of 407 places to eat in Bay Shore

Japanese

May be permanently closed

All restaurants

Salt & Barrel $$$$

#1 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

Open until 8PM

White Cap Fish Market & Seafood Restaurant $$$$

#2 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

Closed until tomorrow

Captain Bills Restaurant & Catering $$$$

#3 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

American

Open until 8:30PM

Chi Fish Market $$$$

#4 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

American

Open until 10PM

Lakehouse $$$$

#5 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

New American

Open until 9:30PM

Whalers $$$$

#6 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

American

Open until 5:30PM

Nicky's Clam Bar $$$$

#7 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

Open until 9PM

Chowder Bar $$$$

#8 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

Open until 7PM

Fatfish $$$$

#9 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

Open until 6:30PM

Deans Seafood $$$$

#10 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

May be permanently closed

Butera's - Bay Shore $$$$

#11 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 9PM

Nicky's On the Bay $$$$

#12 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

Open until 10PM

Nicky's On the Bay $$$$

#13 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

Open until 11PM

Pine Aire Fish and Restaurant $$$$

#14 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

South American

Open until 9PM

Pine Aire Fish, Que Rica Comida $$$$

#15 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Delis

Open until 9PM

ITA Kitchen $$$$

#16 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 9PM

Arthur Treacher's Fish and Chips $$$$

#17 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood

May be permanently closed

King's Chophouse $$$$

#18 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Steakhouses

Open until 9PM

The Linwood Restaurant and Cocktails $$$$

#19 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Cocktail bars

Closed until Tuesday

Aji 53 Japanese Restaurant $$$$

#20 of 64 seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Japanese

Open until 9:55PM

All restaurants

The Pie at Salvatore's $$$$

#1 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 9PM

The Pizzeria of Bay Shore $$$$

#2 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 8PM

Buseto Pizza $$$$

#3 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 9:30PM

The Classic New York Pizza Joint $$$$

#4 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

May be permanently closed

Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant $$$$

#5 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 9PM

Fratelli Pizzeria $$$$

#6 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 10PM

Blaze Pizza $$$$

#7 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 9PM

Bono's Pizzeria $$$$

#8 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 10PM

Marcony Pizza & Pasta Restaurant $$$$

#9 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 10PM

Amore Pizza $$$$

#10 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 9PM

La Casa $$$$

#11 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

May be permanently closed

Victorio II Pizza $$$$

#12 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 9:30PM

Domino's Pizza $$$$

#13 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 12AM

Mulberry Street Bay Shore $$$$

#14 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 8:30PM

Butera's - Bay Shore $$$$

#15 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Italian

Open until 9PM

Mama's Pizza $$$$

#16 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

May be permanently closed

Lil Dominic's Pizza $$$$

#17 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Open until 10PM

Elio's Pizzeria $$$$

#18 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Pizza Hut Express $$$$

#19 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

May be permanently closed

Guarino Delprete Pizza Restaurant $$$$

#20 of 40 pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza

Tasty dishes in Bay Shore

All dishesLess

Restaurant features in Bay Shore

All featuresLess

Cities near Bay Shore

Best restaurants in Bay Shore

/ 236

Sort by

Rating

Sort by

Filters

Map

Restaurants in Bay Shore

Food delivery in Bay Shore

Takeaway restaurants in Bay Shore

Seafood restaurants in Bay Shore

Pizza restaurants in Bay Shore

Tasty dishes in Bay Shore

Restaurant features in Bay Shore

Cities near Bay Shore

Best restaurants in Bay Shore

Sort by

Distance

Price

Search for